19th Hole

Golf bids goodbye to viewer call-ins for rules violations. Should it?

Published

6 years ago

Dec 11, 2017

The nearly 40-year era of viewer call-ins resulting in penalties being assessed to professional golfers will have come to an end by the time PGA Tour pros tee it up at the Sony Open in Hawaii at the beginning of January.

Sad stuff for the eternally maligned armchair rules official.

Effective January 1, via a local rule, professional golf tours will no longer accept calls, emails, texts, messages via carrier pigeon, etc, from fans who believe they’ve seen rules violations (no word on the message they’ll receive if they do place a call). Additionally, the major tours agreed to have at least one rules official watching tournament coverage to keep an eye out for rules violations.

“The message is, have confidence in those conducting the event that if you’ve seen it, they’ve seen it, and there’s no need for anyone to call in what they think they have seen,” said Thomas Pagel, the USGA’s senior director of the Rules of Golf and amateur status.

As far back as the 1980 MONY Tournament of Champions, when a microphone picked up Lee Trevino talking about how Tom Watson gave him a tip during the round led to a viewer call and penalty, armchair rules officiating has been part of the game.

Woods’ bad drop at the 2013 Masters and Lexi Thompson’s bad mark job at the 2017 Ana Inspiration loom large, who can forget Craig Stadler’s “stance building” in 1987, when he knelt on a towel while extricating himself from beneath a tree. Unfortunately for Stadler, the shot wasn’t shown until the next day’s telecast, and he was ultimately disqualified for signing an incorrect third-round scorecard.

There are plenty of hot takes on the demise of one of the most hated elements of rules enforcement.

Geoff Shackelford writes

“…They also stated replay inquiries can occur within the tournament for any round, meaning they might come back the next day and review something with a player. However, this would seem to mean the video replay official missed something, prompting a review. That’s not going to be pretty since most will assume a review a day or two after a round was prompted by social media or a viewer tip. Not accepting fan video is the right move, but what if a Golf Channel crew shooting for highlights shows captures an HD view and angle that exonerates a player?”

The Tour Confidential also team talked through the decision. Josh Sens of Golf Magazine says

“I understand the impulse to want to have as many eyeballs on events as possible, but viewer call-ins opened up a whole can of worms that weren’t worth it.”

Michael Bamberger of Sports Illustrated with the dissenting opinion

“…the rules are complicated, because the playing field is outdoors and so irregular. The more eyes on the players and their golf balls, the better the chances of the player turning in the most accurate scorecard he or she can. This move does not serve that goal. It does make life easier for tournament officials — Tell ’em we’re not home!’

What say you, GolfWRX members? Is the “whole can of worms” not worth it, or “the more eyes on the players and their golf balls, the better…”?

Your Reaction?

LIKE414
LEGIT20
WOW2
LOL2
IDHT0
FLOP2
OB1
SHANK18

19th Hole

Scottie Scheffler arrested, charged, and released after traffic incident at Valhalla

Published

5 hours ago

May 17, 2024

GolfWRX Staff

As first reported by ESPN’s Jeff Darlington, Scottie Scheffler has been detained by police on the way to Valhalla Golf Club this morning due to a traffic misunderstanding.

“Breaking News: World No. 1 golfer Scottie Scheffler has been detained by police in handcuffs after a misunderstanding with traffic flow led to his attempt to drive past a police officer into Valhalla Golf Club. The police officer attempted to attach himself to Scheffler’s car, and Scheffler then stopped his vehicle at the entrance to Valhalla. The police officer then began to scream at Scheffler to get out of the car.

“When Scheffler exited the vehicle, the officer shoved Scheffler against the car and immediately placed him in handcuffs. He is now being detained in the back of a police car.”

Darlington also posted a video of the dramatic moment which you can view below:

Here is video that I took of Scheffler being arrested: https://t.co/8UPZKvPCCf pic.twitter.com/9Tbp2tyrJh

— Jeff Darlington (@JeffDarlington) May 17, 2024

There was an unrelated accident at around 5am, which is what may have caused some of the misunderstanding of which traffic was moving.

Speaking on ESPN, Darlington broke down exactly what he witnessed in full detail:

“Entering Valhalla Golf Club this morning, we witness a car pull around us that was Scottie Scheffler. Scottie Scheffler has been detained by police officers, placed in the back of a police vehicle in handcuffs after he tried to pull around what he believed to be security, ended up being police officers.

“They told him to stop, when he didn’t stop, the police officer attached himself to the vehicle, and Scheffler then travelled another 10 yards before stopping the car.”

“The police officer then grabbed at his arm, attempting to pull him out of the car, before Scheffler eventually opened the door, at which point the police officer pulled Scheffler out of the car, pushed him up against the car and immediately placed him in handcuffs. Scheffler was then walked over to the police car, placed in the back in handcuffs.

“Very stunned about what was happening, he looked towards me as he was in those handcuffs and said ‘please help me’. He very clearly didn’t know what was happening in the situation.”

“It moved very quickly, very rapidly, very aggressively. He was detained in that police vehicle for approximately 20 minutes. The police officers at that point did not understand that Scottie Scheffler was a golfer in the tournament, nor of course that he is the number one player in the world.”

Full details on Scottie Scheffler’s arrest, excellent reporting by @JeffDarlington.

pic.twitter.com/GnRFR9gEgS

— Kevin Negandhi (@KevinNegandhi) May 17, 2024

Due to the accident, play has been delayed this morning. Scheffler’s current tee time for the second round of the PGA Championship is 10:08 a.m.

Scheffler’s mugshot following the incident:

Scottie Scheffler’s mugshot from Louisville Metropolitan Department of Corrections. pic.twitter.com/bcJn54Nu5x

— Golf Digest (@GolfDigest) May 17, 2024

*Update*

Scheffler has been charged with 2nd Degree assault of a police officer, criminal mischief 3rd degree, reckless driving and disregarding signals from an officer directing traffic.

Scottie Scheffler charges

Per: https://t.co/BPBfERxPNn

– 2nd Degree assault of Police officer
– Criminal Mischief 3rd degree
– Reckless driving
– Disregard signals from officer directing traffic pic.twitter.com/bX8mFF2Xay

— sam stone (@sam_rock_stone) May 17, 2024

*Update*

According to ESPN+, Scottie Scheffler has been released and is now on his way to the golf course.

*Update*

Scottie Scheffler arrives at Valhalla ahead of his 10:08 a.m second round tee time.

After being detained by police earlier this morning, Scottie Scheffler was released and is back at Valhalla Golf Club for his second round of the PGA Championship. pic.twitter.com/KvS5Hwo6PS

— TSN (@TSN_Sports) May 17, 2024

*Update*

The PGA of America released this statement regarding the fatal accident, which diverted traffic at Valhalla this morning.

“This morning we were devastated to learn that a worker with one of our vendors was tragically struck and killed by a shuttle bus outside Valhalla Golf Club. This is heartbreaking to all of us involved with the PGA Championship. We extend our sincere condolences to their family and loved ones.”

Per the PGA Tour, Scheffler released the following statement.

Scottie Scheffler’s statement prior to Round 2 @PGAChampionship. pic.twitter.com/x26RFOqCIa

— PGA TOUR (@PGATOUR) May 17, 2024

We will update this developing story as more information on the situation is revealed.

New here?

Find out more about GolfWRX and the GolfWRX forums.

Your Reaction?

LIKE14
LEGIT3
WOW17
LOL5
IDHT1
FLOP0
OB0
SHANK9

19th Hole

Butch Harmon reveals what he worked on with Rory McIlroy during visit earlier this year

Published

1 day ago

May 16, 2024

Matt Vincenzi

While speaking on the “Son of a Butch” Podcast, legendary swing coach Butch Harmon revealed what he worked on with Rory McIlroy when the four-time major champion went to visit him after the Players Championship this season.

Butch Harmon on what he worked on with Rory:

“The work I did with him wasn’t a tremendous amount of changing what he did, it was his attitude and the way he played certain shots. From 150 yards and in he made a full swing like he was hitting a driver and I wanted him to make…

— Matt Vincenzi (@MattVincenziPGA) May 15, 2024

“The work I did with him wasn’t a tremendous amount of changing what he did, it was his attitude and the way he played certain shots. From 150 yards and in he made a full swing like he was hitting a driver and I wanted him to make more 3 quarter swings and chop the follow through off a little. He’s a very high ball hitter, but with short irons high balls aren’t good, it’s hard to control, we wanted to bring the ball flight down.”

The work certainly seemed to help McIlroy, as he went on to win the Zurich Classic alongside Shane Lowry and the Wells Fargo Championship at Quail Hollow in back-to-back starts.

Rory will now tee it up at Valhalla for the PGA Championship, which is the site of his most recent major victory in 2014.

New here?

Find out more about GolfWRX and the GolfWRX forums.

Your Reaction?

LIKE5
LEGIT2
WOW0
LOL0
IDHT0
FLOP0
OB0
SHANK1

19th Hole

Brandel Chamblee says this technological development was key to Phil Mickelson winning major championships

Published

1 day ago

May 16, 2024

Matt Vincenzi

While speaking with GolfWRX, Golf Channel’s Brandel Chamblee shared that he believes the solid core golf ball helped Phil Mickelson win major championships.

“One of the consequences of the solid core golf ball coming around was it put the straightest of hitters in the rough.

“Phil started winning majors in 2004, I don’t think that’s any coincidence. I think he started winning majors after the solid core golf ball came along and put everybody in the rough.

“And so [Phil] is like ‘I got you in the rough, I’m going to kick your a**. This is my game. I’ve been in the rough my whole career. I can go over trees, through trees, around trees.’

“Because he’s got that amazing creativity and Phil is an underrated iron player, phenomenal iron player. Great, great great out of the trouble. If you put the top-40 players on a list and ranked them in terms of accuracy, he would be 40th.

“So, I think that was one of the consequences of the solid core golf balls was it allowed Phil to win major championships.”

Mickelson went on to win the Masters in 2004 as well as five additional majors from 2004-2021 including three total Masters, two PGA Championships, and an Open Championship.

Check out the full interview with Chamblee below: