Best courses in Twin Cities, MN Looking for a hidden gem
#1
Posted 11 May 2007 - 05:20 PM
The problem is I seemed to have fallen into a rut. I keep trying new courses but most of them suck.
I normally play in St. Paul and Western WI.
Here are my favorites on no particular order. Anyone have something I should try?
Troy Burne
StoneRidge
Logger's Trail
Mississippi Dunes
White Eagle
St. Croix National
I have played most of the rest of the public courses on the East side.
Does the west side have anything to offer. I have tried the Lakeville, Burnsville area only to be disappointed.
Any help I enjoy playing all different courses, but most have not been worth the drive or green fees.
Thanks for any help.
Ryan
#6
Posted 12 May 2007 - 07:31 AM
Of the courses I've played and liked: St. Croix National (heard they were going condo); Purple Hawk; New Richmond. Learned the game at Phalen and Keller (3-4 x / week!) as a youngster, but can't comment on what's happened to them.
#7
Posted 12 May 2007 - 07:45 AM
#9
Posted 12 May 2007 - 04:58 PM
If you were looking for great private courses the westerns suburbs you would have to many to choose from. ICC, windsong, MGC, Hazeltine, Spring Hill...
#10
Posted 14 May 2007 - 02:31 PM
I have played the legends. The lake hole is cool but the rest of the course didn't really impress me with all the houses around.
I will be playing Rush Creek this coming weekend I will see if I like that one.
Chaska Town Course is next on my list.
I tried to play the Wild as a single last year, and they wouldn't get me on for 4+ hours since they said they were booked full. I was not real happy about that so I haven't been back. I do believe the course is full of homes as well.
I did find a new course that I enjoyed. Tanner's Brook. Good shape, resonable, nice layout and no houses.
Anything else on the west side not private worth checking out.
#11
Posted 14 May 2007 - 02:43 PM
#12
Posted 14 May 2007 - 03:54 PM
Almost makes one want to move back to the once frozen tundra (thanks to global warming.)
#13
Posted 14 May 2007 - 11:41 PM
#14
Posted 15 May 2007 - 12:38 AM
#15
Posted 15 May 2007 - 12:55 PM
Hairpie, on May 15 2007, 12:38 AM, said:
Edinburgh is in decent shape these days. Nothing spectacular for the cost really. They are finishing up re-doing the ponds on the course so they hold water again (it was pretty ugly there for a number of years.)
Tanners Brook is my home course, but its a bit messy with a new clubhouse going up (done in July.) Very links style front 9 and overall, with a little woods on the back. Play is starting off the 10th due to clubhouse construction. One tough par 4.
One hidden gem I discovered last season was up at the National Sports Center in Blaine (a.k.a. "Victory Links.") It was designed by the PGA Tour and has some nice holes on it. Great greens. Ridiculous layout though. Some holes have 1/4 mile walk between them (and its a course set up for First tee juniors, so that makes it all the more ridiculous with the long walks.) Course backs up to the local airport. Just great golf holes set on garbage land. Very odd. Worth trying though. Kind of urban golf.
Rush Creek this weekend for my birthday (free green fee on your B-day via website. WORD!)
Links at NorthFork (also free B-day round.) Fun course. Wish they'd let it dry out and play hard and fast.
Also want to check out the Chaska Town Course.
Bunker Hills is always a good test.
Stone Ridge/Troy Burne are great. Go during the Spring/Fall rates. Too much money otherwise.
They keep adverstising this "Big Fish Golf" in Wisconsion in the local Pioneer Press. Pete Dye course. Anyone been there?
#16
Posted 15 May 2007 - 02:05 PM
Twin Cities Area:
Public -
Rush Creek (maple grove)
Ledgends (lakeville)
The Wilds (savage)
Stonebrooke (shakopee)
Stone Ridge (woodbury???)
Breamar (edina)
Private -
Interlachen (Edina)...2007 Womens US Open
Olympic Hills (Eden Prairie)
Minnesota Valley Country Club (Bloomington)...US AM qualifying site in 2004
North:
Public -
Classic at Madden's (Brainerd)
Giant's Ridge (Biwabik..spelling)
The Wilderness (Tower)
Private -
Northland CC (Duluth)
South:
Private -
Rochester CC (rochester) ... a tillinghast design
Sombery GC (byron) ... home of the 2007 Nationwide Scholarship Showdown
#17
Posted 18 May 2007 - 10:00 AM
I played the Meadows at Mystic Lake.
I played the Super Twilight. For $35 it is a great deal. At full price, no way.
They have a decent location except for that giant casino that you can see from every hole. The holes were too close together, always someone in your fairway from another hole. The last 3 holes were nice. It is a tough course with all the water and sand.
Rush Creek tomorrow, I hope it is better.
So far I will stick to the east side. Chaska will get a chance soon.
Here is my take. Eastside way better public, Westside way better private.
#18
Posted 18 May 2007 - 11:38 AM
You can certainly tell they spent a fortune on the place. The $35 super twilight is a steal, but their $85 typical green fee is way too much. Courses such as Troy Burne and Stone Ridge that also have bent grass tee to green seemed much better groomed in comparison. I know we have had dry weather, but it was like all the grass aside from the rough at Mystic was a little dry. Fairways were a little shaggy. Greens were nice and fast, although they were a bit bumpy and had a few putts wander off line.
Something about going around the giant maze of concrete cart paths made it feel more like a golf cart track than a golf course. It seemed like an easily walkable course, but given that there is no break price-wise for walking, there is little incentive to do so. I agree, the last 3 holes were pretty good (probably because they are furthest away from the casino, (save for the 18th having the casino as the backdrop behind the green.) The cart GPS seemed off on a couple water holes. Had 115 yards showing to the pin on 16. Hit a pretty good GW with a wind at my back (my 115 club) and came up about 20 yards short. Flushed a PW from the same spot, and was 4 feet from the hole (my 135 club.) I kind of chuckled as we looked upon another group coming up 16 and kept hearing "splash" after "splash." It wasn't until I played the hole myself that I understood. Anyone have a scuba mask handy? I bet there are LOTS of balls in that pond.
Overall, there was just something about the holes where none of them really stood out from one another. A couple of the par 4's I literally thought to myself, "Didn't we already play this hole?" I could see playing the twilight or super twilight if you live on that side of town. But 90 miles round trip for me is not worth the hike. Beware post round "club washer$" looking for a handout, and the fact the parking lot is about 500 yards from the clubhouse and they won't let you take the carts to your car to drop off your clubs for some odd reason. (Again, eager attendent$ waiting with carts to drive you out there.) The place is just too "Urban" in feel for me I suppose, with all the asphault close by and the Casino. They try to be "upscale" but it just doesn't feel it.
#19
Posted 18 May 2007 - 12:24 PM
Private:
Windsong - Once termed Minneapolis CC West....this is a bruisers golf course, long, dry, awesome! Best greens in the state, personal favorite.
Hazeltine - Long, THICK rough. Tournament track record and I have seen legit 2's post 95. It can drive you nuts! Play the right tees to enhance the experience. Try a "transfussion"
Olympic Hills - Love it. Great social club. If you are moving to Minneapolis, look at joining. They have a young membership chalked full of professional athletes. FUN golf course. Everything you could want in a private club. I predict they will finish #2 in city league this year!
Minnekhada - I fell in love there a few years back during a practice round for the State Am. MC thank you very little! Standing on the #18 green, watching some racked out bombalati drink a cosmo with DT Minneapolis as the back drop. Minnutes from Uptown, grab a piece of fish and a drink on the rooftop @ Stellas. You'll be loving life.
Public:
CTC: Chaska Town Course - The price has gone up, and at last years AM it played easy, but this is a good track. A lot of birdies out there and a laid back feel. Affordable, fun, good shape. Head to Heart Breakers for a discounted pitcher!
The Wilds - I still like it. If you are looking for a place to play in the Spring or Fall, head to Prior Lake where you will pay the temp. Casino is walking distance and it makes for a great day with the guys....too bad there are no ripper clubs close!
The Classic - It's not in the cities, but sue me! It's a 10+ If you are not from the midwest and you want to get a solid bang for your buck, head up North! Great facility, well priced for the course is a bear (you might actually see one) from the tips!
Face it....MN is cold as hell for 6.5 months a year, thats why God invented Arizona! But there really is no better place to play golf during the summer! If you are thinking about getting out. Do a little research, try and get on to one of the courses I've listed and I promise you'll thank me! Great thing about living/working here....A lot of companies have half day Friday!!!!! LATER Gent's tee time in 90 min!
Cheers!
#21
Posted 18 May 2007 - 02:41 PM
I have tried politely asking the courses if I could play as a guest when they are not busy. Hazeltine was the only one to respond saying I could, when they weren't busy, but that never seemed to happen.
I will keep up the search.
As far as best in the state, Giants Ridge and Wilderness at Fortune bay blow everything away around the cities. Can't wait to get up there again on June 8th.
#22
Posted 19 May 2007 - 06:53 PM
Rush Creek was nice. It wasn't too hard without wind, but the 30 mph wind on the last 3 holes was brutal.
Decent shape, not spectacular, but good, fun layout. Only problem too much $$ for a 5+ hour round. Edit:(I wasn't paying attention to when our tee-time was, yeah only 4 hours. Isn't wasn't as slow time wise as it felt on the back nine. Front nine was excellent speed. Back nine really slowed down. That might be because of the layout, there are some really tough holes on the back around the marsh/swamp)
Nothing to wow me back, but a very nice track. If I lived on the west side I would play it more for sure.
Now when can I start checking out the privates??
#23
Posted 19 May 2007 - 09:54 PM
rlheiman, on May 18 2007, 02:41 PM, said:
I have tried politely asking the courses if I could play as a guest when they are not busy. Hazeltine was the only one to respond saying I could, when they weren't busy, but that never seemed to happen.
I will keep up the search.
As far as best in the state, Giants Ridge and Wilderness at Fortune bay blow everything away around the cities. Can't wait to get up there again on June 8th.
It was about 4 hours. We did run into a few slow groups, but it really wasn't that slow. We teed off at 1:40 and were done by about 5:50 PM.
I enjoyed Rush Creek. Conditions were good. Greens I thought were a little bumpy, but I think that is from over-watering. They rolled at a medium clip. A little slower than other courses in this price range. Nice white sand soft bunkers.
One gripe- the yardage poles. I was fooled twice by them. Most courses, you have a 150 pole, and then plates at 100 and 200. On one shortish par 4, I pulled my tee shot left and had to hit around a bush. I saw what I thought to be the 150 pole to my right, pulled 8 iron, and executed a shot I was truly proud of that was tracking right at the pin. To my dismay, it ended up about 35 yards long, as it was a 100 yard pole on that hole!! Who the heck has a 100 yard pole when all the rest of them have been 150's!!! Grrr...
Another hole, what turned out to be a long par 4, I thought I saw the 150 pole smack dab in the middle of the fairway on the crest of a hill. Pulled 3 wood, as it was about 250 out. Get to my ball and have 200+ left to the pin (Pinseeker 1500.) That blew. Made big numbers on those holes because of that.
Other than that, I really liked the course. Very fair layout for the most part with not many blind shots. Nice setting with no houses save for one par 3. Conditions were good. $80 good? Not quite. Fortunately, it was my B-day today and we got to split the cost of one round. It was a fairly easy walk overall if you are reasonably fit. The front side had a couple par 4's back to back that were a little too similar in length. Par 4 13th hole is one devilish little hole. Look out for that one! 18 is an absolute bear as well- especially with a 30 MPH wind. Probably one of the toughest finishing holes I have played here in the cities.
Definitely worth checking out though if you haven't played here before.
#24
Posted 19 May 2007 - 10:05 PM
Ryan, if you play at a course regularly, your PGA pro can usually arrange T-times at private courses. You usually end up paying the guest rate (w/o member) which is usually a but higher. I played TPC twin cities this way. It was $175.
Hillcrest in St. Paul is an awesome "Golfers" club. It's always in great shape and a really walkable private course in the city (Mcknight and Larpentuer.) If you and Divots are interested, I think I can arrange a 4Some, and we can give it a go. Another one I wanted to try was the Hudson CC in Hudson, WI. I have never played it, I have played Hillcrest though and really enjoyed it.
If you know an employee at 3M, the Tartan Park course is a REALLY CHEAP private course to try. Not as well maintained as a typical private course, but nice enough for the money.
For others looking for a nice course, I must also plug the Sanctum Sanctorum, White Eagle in Hudson: www.whiteeaglegolf.com
BTW, Happy Birthday Divots!
#25
Posted 19 May 2007 - 10:18 PM
My Dad used to have a corporate out at HillCrest when I was in H.S. (many moons ago.) I got to tag along every once in a while and had fun playing there. Lots of hilly lies (HillCrest- go figure!) They tout themselves as having the "Best greens in the Twin Cities" in their recent ads. Would be fun to play it again now that my game is A LOT better than it was in H.S.
#26
Posted 20 May 2007 - 06:02 AM
I played Hillcrest last fall. It was as always in excellent shape, and lately it doesn't look like it gets lots of play. (I drive by it everyday) The layout is tight and short. The worst layout for a first hole. from club house to 1st tee, you have to drive infront of the tee-boxes and then back to the tee. I can't believe someone has not gotten hit by a tee shot, not knowing someone was teeing off and going to the first tee. But other than that, nice old school private course, that I would imagine someday might go public, they are hurting for members. It would be fun to play again.
I also did find a connection to a private course. I might be able to get a 4some on Hudson CC. I will check into it.
I also will put a plug in for white eagle, it is one of my favorite courses around, very hilly, can be very tough, and super scenic. Only detraction is I really enjoy walking when I play, and for those that have been to white eagle know it is impossible. You would have to be an olympic athlete to walk that course. from 10 to 11 is a long drive over the hills, under the road, etc.
#27
Posted 20 May 2007 - 07:05 AM
What I really like about MN golf is the seemingly endless selection of reasonably priced public and semi-private courses, something not as easy to come by in the greater NYC area.
#28
Posted 20 May 2007 - 07:29 AM
#29
Posted 20 May 2007 - 10:26 AM
Heres my top 5 public
1.)Quarry
2.)Wilderness
3.)Legends (Giants ridge)
4.)Troy Burne
5.)Deacons Lodge
#30
Posted 20 May 2007 - 11:39 AM
1) Hidden Greens in Hastings (very cool little course cut through the woods)
2) Bellwood Oaks (right next door to Hidden Greens)
3) New Richmond (already mentioned -- a true gem, hidden away)
4) Keller in St. Paul/Maplewood
5) Inverwood (short, but difficult track -- maybe the nicest muni next to Chaska)
6) Cannon Falls Golf Club (also difficult, but a cool little course that is overlooked)
7) Crystal Lake (Burnsville?)
8)
You can walk all of these (Inverwood is a challenge to walk though) for less than $35, some for less than $25 at times.
And, to add a few that I think are over-rated, over-priced, or not worth the time:
1) Summit (near Cannon Falls GC) - a long way for a decent course
2) St. Croix Natl (a joke carved out of old ski slopes -- a lot like Afton Alps). Pricey too as I recall.
3) Afton Alps -- back nine is ridiculous target golf, used nine iron on par 4 tees
4) Chaska -- nice, but not worth the $ in my opinion. Legends is better.
5) Prestwick in Woodbury -- too much $
6) Purple Hawk (read about it, drove a long way to play it, but not worth the drive if you live south)
7) Legacy -- another long drive for an average course
It is amazing how much great golf there is here when I think through all of these courses. I wonder if anywhere else in the US has as much golf per capita, especially at this quality and these prices.
#31
Posted 20 May 2007 - 09:01 PM
maskedman, on May 20 2007, 07:05 AM, said:
What I really like about MN golf is the seemingly endless selection of reasonably priced public and semi-private courses, something not as easy to come by in the greater NYC area.
Maskedman,
Tanner's Brook is open (it's my home track.) The new clubhouse is under construction, and is supposed to be done sometime in July. The course is in great shape. The only thing that has been affected by the construction is that play is starting off #10 due to cart parking logistics.
#32
Posted 24 May 2007 - 04:12 PM
I don't think it rates among the best of the best, but I like playing Gross in NE Mpls. Old school course, very walkable.
I miss being able to play Mississippi Dunes on a regular basis. It's a love it or hate it course and I'm a huge fan.
Lived in the Cities for more than 10 years and the only private courses I played were Olympic Hills (pretty nice) and Brackett's Crossing (nothing special). Sad.
#33
Posted 06 June 2007 - 05:10 PM
If you live on the east side and just want to get in a quick 9 the ponds at battle creek is awesome. 3 par 3s, 3 par 4s and 4 par 5s. It is tough from the tips. Usually in really great shape and easy to get on, never too crowded and a decent practice area and range.
Hole 4 is really a pretty hole.
A hidden gem.
On Friday get to play 2 of the best in MN the Quarry and the Legend. Can't wait. I will give an update on conditions when I get back.
Enjoy golf in MN between the storms and rain lately.
#34
Posted 07 June 2007 - 09:52 AM
rlheiman, on Jun 6 2007, 05:10 PM, said:
If you live on the east side and just want to get in a quick 9 the ponds at battle creek is awesome. 3 par 3s, 3 par 4s and 4 par 5s. It is tough from the tips. Usually in really great shape and easy to get on, never too crowded and a decent practice area and range.
Hole 4 is really a pretty hole.
A hidden gem.
On Friday get to play 2 of the best in MN the Quarry and the Legend. Can't wait. I will give an update on conditions when I get back.
Enjoy golf in MN between the storms and rain lately.
The Quarry is in good shape. The Legend suffered freeze damage to their greens and is still somewhat in the grown-in stage.
Have fun!
Texsport
#36
Posted 09 June 2007 - 10:48 PM
We had a blast on Friday. Left at 6:15 am and got to the Quarry by about 9:30. After a warm up at the range, we were off. About 65 and very windy (around 20-25 MPH I would say.)
The Quarry definitely impressed. Nice conditions. Challenging but fair. No blind shots for the most part (although there were a few yardages that seemed off in the provided yardage book.) One par 4 in particular the fairway runs out at what the book said was 235 yards, so I hit 5 iron dead down the fairway and still went through the fairway for a lost ball. The Quarry was a great strategic course, yet it was not overly punitive. From peoples' comments I had heard, I was expecting a bloodbath score-wise, but it wasn't that bad (can you tell I was having a good ball striking day?) I must be really hard to impress or something though, as I kind of expected something "more" about the course. It was great, but 500 miles round trip great? Not sure.
The Legend I really enjoyed (aside from killer gnats that left my arms looking like I have the measles now!) It was a more scenic and "up North" feeling course, where as the Quarry sits, well, down in a quarry, and doesn't offer as many views of the surrounding area. The dead greens at the Legend were quite perplexing. All of the grass around the greens (which appears to be bentgrass) was in superb shape, as well as the fairways and tee boxes. Just the greens were dead. (When I say dead, I don't mean burnt patches, I mean dirt with sparse bits of green.) I've seen winter kill on bentgrass before. This was something different. Me thinks someone secretly replace the Folgers Crytals fertilizer with weed killer or something accidentally and burned them to death. I was like a chemical spill on the greens.
Aside from all that, the 17th hole at the Legend has to be the coolest hole I've ever played. 220 over a lake from an elevated tee to an elevate green that sits about 20 feet above the edge of the lake. I'm really glad we made the trip. Not sure I can recommend being crazy and driving 6 hours and playing 36 in a day like we did, but it made for one heckuva fun day trip. I slept 'til noon today though!!
#37
Posted 09 June 2007 - 11:21 PM
Did you guys go for it or lay up on the landing area? Glad you guys had a good time...can't believe you went all that way and did not play the Legend at Fortune Bay! It would have been worth an overnight at the Casino. You could have won back your green fees!!!
#39
Posted 10 June 2007 - 09:47 PM
mr_divots, on Jun 9 2007, 10:48 PM, said:
We had a blast on Friday. Left at 6:15 am and got to the Quarry by about 9:30. After a warm up at the range, we were off. About 65 and very windy (around 20-25 MPH I would say.)
The Quarry definitely impressed. Nice conditions. Challenging but fair. No blind shots for the most part (although there were a few yardages that seemed off in the provided yardage book.) One par 4 in particular the fairway runs out at what the book said was 235 yards, so I hit 5 iron dead down the fairway and still went through the fairway for a lost ball. The Quarry was a great strategic course, yet it was not overly punitive. From peoples' comments I had heard, I was expecting a bloodbath score-wise, but it wasn't that bad (can you tell I was having a good ball striking day?) I must be really hard to impress or something though, as I kind of expected something "more" about the course. It was great, but 500 miles round trip great? Not sure.
The Legend I really enjoyed (aside from killer gnats that left my arms looking like I have the measles now!) It was a more scenic and "up North" feeling course, where as the Quarry sits, well, down in a quarry, and doesn't offer as many views of the surrounding area. The dead greens at the Legend were quite perplexing. All of the grass around the greens (which appears to be bentgrass) was in superb shape, as well as the fairways and tee boxes. Just the greens were dead. (When I say dead, I don't mean burnt patches, I mean dirt with sparse bits of green.) I've seen winter kill on bentgrass before. This was something different. Me thinks someone secretly replace the Folgers Crytals fertilizer with weed killer or something accidentally and burned them to death. I was like a chemical spill on the greens.
Aside from all that, the 17th hole at the Legend has to be the coolest hole I've ever played. 220 over a lake from an elevated tee to an elevate green that sits about 20 feet above the edge of the lake. I'm really glad we made the trip. Not sure I can recommend being crazy and driving 6 hours and playing 36 in a day like we did, but it made for one heckuva fun day trip. I slept 'til noon today though!!
Did you play The Quarry from the tips? The par 4 where the fairaway runs out is either #13 or #15.
From the back on #13, the fairway does run out at 220 but the wind is generally from behind--and if it was 20mph, from that very high tee, would explain your long shot!
#15 runs out at about 260 on the right side of the fairway if you're playing the tips---but it's about 235 on the left side. Another shot with that big tail wind!
Where were the pins on The Quarry? When they put all the pins back the course can be stretched to nearly 7,500 yds!!!!
When they put them in the centers of the greens, the approaches aren't too tough---but when they tuck them---it's a different game----can be 5-10 shots harder!
Toughest Pin Examples:
#2---on the very back--multilevel green, putting up 2 or 3 levels is difficult and recovering from severe downhill lie over the green is tough.
#4---back---makes the hole a 280 yd. par 3.
#5---back---very deep green with humps across green make you carry it all the way.
#6---left back near the pit behind the green or anywhere near the depression in the center can turn a short hole into a disaster.
#7---far right--miss green right and lost ball results.
#8---back center in neck--makes hole a semi-blind approach, nearly 500 yd par 4 which plays 10-15 yards longer because of the uphill approach shot.
#9---hidden from fairway on far right makes it difficult to hit it close unless you lay up down the left. Tee shot to right prevents shot to right pin--blocked by big hill on right side of fairway.
#12--right side near grass bunkers and mounds---miss to the right is a very tough short sided, up and down from deep grass.
#13--pin on far right makes approach from left fairway to very small green area. Tee shot to right with tough, semi-blind 2nd also difficult to get close to the pin. Chipping or putting from the wrong level to very sloped and multi-level green very difficult--bogies are common.
#14--hidden behind mounds on right makes hitting it close a blind crap shoot unless you lay up way left. Also, the hidden pond behind mound to right of green is then also in play for attempts to get home in 2 or misdirected 3rd shots. Most 1st time players don't even know it's there!
#15--right back makes hole play 475 yds, par 4.
#16--right side--grenn sloped away to the right---shots bounce off.
#17--left side--left side bunker is tough--high lip.
#18--back right--very deep green--makes hole play 480 yds and forces a carry over the corner of the lake all the way back.
When they played the MNPGA Club Pro Championships there last year, the pins were brutal. Of 137 rounds played by pros on The Quarry over 2 days, only 16 rounds were recorded at even par or better! First and 3rd rounds at Quarry. 2nd round at Legends.
http://www.minnesota...om/2006/cpc.asp
How'd you like #13? It's generally regarded as one of the greatest short par 4s in the world. The Head pro at The Quarry reaches the green with a 3 wood but it's 323 yds, the equivalent of about a 270 yard carry! Most people try to lay up to the left plateau--the one that runs out at 220 yds. The fairway pot bunker that's right there, between the left plateau and the lower right fairway is a true hazard. You frequently have to blast out sideways or backwards because of the high greenside lip.
Texsport
#40
Posted 11 June 2007 - 08:55 AM
One I haven't seen listed for the guys who live down by me (Farmington) is Boulder Pointe. I played it a couple years ago when they first opened and from what I remember it is a pretty nice course. My memory might be fading so don't hold me to it.





Sign In
Register
Help


Quote













