A few comments on this travel bag topic. I've been traveling with clubs for the past 25 years. I've traveled with canvas covers, padded covers, hard sided cases, and hard sided golf bags. My preferance is the hard sided golf bags which serve as protective travel case and on course carry / cart bag. Over the past 10 years I have favored the Cargo Golf brand of travel bag. There are a few other brands on the market now, all share the same design. The protective case is designed to solidly protect the clubs with a removeable top. Depending on design (I use the Cargo Golf 700 Series), the bag can hold a full set of clubs (I use a Titleist 910D3 most of the time, but can shoehorn in a D2 if needed). The removable top is held in place during travel with a throughpin, which is held in place with a removable clasp for airport inspection. The lower portion of the bag incorporates zippered pockets roomy enough for carry straps, balls, tees, gloves, etc. The complete bag is wheeled, very compact, and light. The compactness of this bag makes it tolerable to travel with through airports. The bag is also very trunk friendly - another aspect to consider when traveling. I've recently gotten this bag into a Fiat500. As far as usage is concerned, I typically travel with my clubs twice a month. That means at least 4 if not 8 or 12 loading/unloading cycles on airplanes, baggage handlers throwing the bags and carousels beating them up. The outside pockets do get wear and tear, to the point where I've removed some of the damaged pockets. Those bags with the removed pockets make great compact club storage bags (my problem with too many clubs)!
I used to be bummed about not traveling with my own carry bag, but this hard sided bag is light enough for a full round carry. The upside of the bags mentioned above is certainly the use of your own bag on the road - that's a nice plus. However, the compactness of the Cargo Golf style hardsided bags is a bonus for me, as I can manage a wheeled suitcase with my pilots bag strapped to it, a shoe bag on top of that and the golf clubs in the other hand without a problem. The weight of the hard sided bag, a full complement of clubs along with the Scotty Cameron Detour putter, and all accessories, never topped 35lbs. So no over size or overweight charges at the airport.
Hope this helps!
Edited by valveman, 01 December 2012 - 04:19 PM.