Pros/cons 55g vs 65g driver shaft
Posted 05 August 2011 - 07:22 PM
Posted 07 August 2011 - 09:23 PM
Posted 07 August 2011 - 10:08 PM
Posted 07 August 2011 - 11:35 PM
Adams Super 9031 16 & 20
Miura Small Blades 3 - PW, 51 & 55
SC Square Back Select
Swift X & Ping Moonlite bags
MG Tour C4 balls
Posted 08 August 2011 - 05:24 AM
Swing weight went from D3 to D8, but driver feels very "solid" and dispersion of the shots was great - 11/14 fairways hit today, with my longest drive at 296
The stock TFC is 55 g in an R, 60 g in an S. If you were swinging an R TFC (maybe even the S!) at 104, you wouldn't have liked it at ANY weight.
Posted 15 August 2011 - 03:22 PM
Edited by onetime19, 15 August 2011 - 03:23 PM.
Posted 15 August 2011 - 04:50 PM
The weight of the shaft is the predominant controller of the TOTAL WEIGHT of the club. Meaning how many grams or ounces does the whole club weigh. Total weight is fit to the golfer on the basis of their downswing transition force, their downswing acceleration aggressiveness, and also on the basis of how physically strong is the golfer and do they use that strength in their swing. The idea is you want the weight of the club to match the tempo, aggressiveness and strength of the golfer so as to end up with more shot consistency, better swing tempo consistency, and a higher percentage of on center hits.
The more forceful and aggressive the swing, the higher the total weight of the club should be - which means the heavier the weight of the shaft should be. And vice versa, the more passive and rhythmic and smooth the swing tempo, the lighter the total weight should be and lighter the weight of the shaft needs to be.
It is also true that the lighter the total weight of the club, meaning the lighter the weight of the shaft, the golfer should be able to see a little higher clubhead speed and from it, more distance. However, it usually requires the golfer to drop the weight of the shaft by at least 20-25 grams before they see a 1mph increase in clubhead speed. Then you have the matter of can you still hit the ball on center the highest percentage of the time with a much lighter total weight in the club. If the lighter weight club results in a higher percentage of off center hits than before, any clubhead speed increase from going lighter is never going to turn into more distance than before.
Typically when you have a strong, aggressive golfer who uses a very light shaft such as sub 60g or sub 50g, they can tend to get even more quick with their swing tempo and from this, suffer from a higher percentage of off center hits or suffer from a worse swing path movement through the ball. It IS possible to offset some of this "too light feeling" of a more aggressive golfer using a very light shaft by increasing the swingweight (headweight) of the club and still keep the total weight of the club lower than if you used a heavier shaft. Adding weight to the head can give such a golfer the sense that there is enough weight out there so they might not end up getting too quick.
The difference between a 55g and 65g shaft to most golfers is minimal and hardly shows up. This is because of 2 reasons. For one, the obvious one, 10 grams is just not very much weight and many golfers just cannot feel that reduction in weight over the whole length of the club. Drop 10g from the head and sure, they feel that. But 10g of shaft weight is over the whole length of the shaft so most golfers don't feel it. The other reason is because if you switch from a 65g to 55g shaft and you want the club with the 55g shaft to play to the same swingweight as you had it before, you'll have to add some weight to the head once the 55g shaft is installed. This weight addition to get the swingweight back to where it was then acts to reverse some of the lighter total weight obtained from the 10g drop in the shaft weight.
For most golfers, to really experience a visible and perceptible change in the weight of the club from a shaft weight change, that shaft weight change has to be closer to 20 grams or more.
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users