32 replies to this topic

[phillyj23]

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

[benthegolfer]

I just picked up a set of AP1 710 Irons. I'm a 10. Alot of people seemed to be pushing the AP2s, and I am normally a high ball hitter. I don't see why I didn't switch earlier. The AP1s are a great in between club. I feel like my handicap is going to go down, because I'm hitting the ball alot more consistently which enables me to hit more greens. I might consider adding something like the AP2 or 710 CB in the 7-PW later down the roadas my ballstriking improves, but for now, I don't see any reason to hit something else. I'm able to pull off any shots I need, and the long irons are extremely easy to hit for a 10 handicapper. Good luck!

[echelon2011]

phillyj23, on 20 January 2011 - 12:36 PM, said:

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

Have a look at Mizuno MX300. Mizuno MP53, Mizuno MP58 and Mizuno MP63.

Do not, And I really must stress this, buy a set of irons before you hit the Mizunos.

It's a huge difference between cast and forged clubs, but an equally large difference between properly forged clubs and clubs that are basicly cast and then pounded once in a machine.

[simonj]

+1 on above. Mp58 for me am.

[dblung]

I play to an 11 handicap and I have no trouble with the MX-300's. On days when I am stricking the ball well I wish I would have went with the mp-58's. But more days than not I am glad I have the added forgivenss and still get the forged feel. I believe they discontinued the 300's but the I believe JPX pro model took it's place. Give em a look you won't be dissapointed.

[Jimbud]

I'm in the 9 or 10 range and bought the MX-200 irons last year to replace my J33cb's.  I bought the Mizuno irons solely on the fact that the long irons are so easy to hit.  As said above the MX-300 would be a great choice too.

[Smoothduffer]

I'm at 15 and, my Wilson Staff Ci9's are perfect for me.

[DavePelz4]

My handicap is in the same range and 2 years ago I got fit and ended up with the Mizuno MX 200's.  Had never hit Mizunos before and found them to be incredibly forgiving. They were far and away the easiest to hit and you can work the ball with them.

[zzyzxx33]

If I were you I would find a good club fitter to help. Also take your old clubs with you so you can compare the new clubs too.

[twgolf]

AP2 710s

If you are a ten, then you are more than likely a decent ball strikers and would have no problems with them.  Super easy to hit and hit straight, yet easy to work the ball with.  I have have said for a long time that the Ping I5s were the best and easiest players cavity back irons, until I switched to the AP2 710s.  Believe the the hype they are that good!

[Srixon-Ian]

I highly recommend the srixon I 701's, tour if you work the ball or normal if you want a bit more forgiveness. These are also a bargain as they can be had on eBay for 230 dollars or less even with upgraded shafts. I have a set that I love, I just decided to go super crazy combo setup with the srixon I 701, 3-5 irons, I 701 tour 6&7, then pro 100 8-pw. Just cause I have all three sets and love them all

http://cgi.ebay.com/...7#ht_1213wt_689
Just an example of what is out there

[SpinMill75]

Find a really fitter that has a driving range that allows you to hit off real grass, not a mat.  Have an open mind to all the brands he/she can show you then hit them all......whatever one works best is the one you want to buy.  

There, I just saved you alot of time and money.....

Cheers.

[Meurig]

+1 Go see a fitter!

SpinMill75, on 21 January 2011 - 01:32 AM, said:

Find a really fitter that has a driving range that allows you to hit off real grass, not a mat.  Have an open mind to all the brands he/she can show you then hit them all......whatever one works best is the one you want to buy.  

There, I just saved you alot of time and money.....

Cheers.

[max power]

18 years old/10 handicap-honestly, whatever you want.  There isn't a new set of irons that you couldn't hit with a little practice.  If you want forgiveness with maximum feel then the MX-200 is a great recommendation.  If you want player's cavities or blades then go for it.  My brother is around a 10-12 and he murders the ball with the MacGregor MT Pro-M irons I gave him.  I don't think anything else is less forgiving (other than older blades).

[haydos]

Adams CB1 - you can handle them and they'll be good enough for you all the way down to scratch.

[PAYLEE]

twgolf, on 21 January 2011 - 01:10 AM, said:

AP2 710s

If you are a ten, then you are more than likely a decent ball strikers and would have no problems with them.  Super easy to hit and hit straight, yet easy to work the ball with.  I have have said for a long time that the Ping I5s were the best and easiest players cavity back irons, until I switched to the AP2 710s.  Believe the the hype they are that good!

+1 on the AP2 710s. I own a set and seeing that you are a ten handicap these clubs will perform well for you.

I like the forgiveness that the set provides while maintaining a thinner top line and hidden cavity/insert. The forged 1025 steel body with multi-metel sole and insert (tungsten, nickel, aluminum, etc.) make the feel a tad harder than a strictly forged 1025 steel body and sole like my Srixon i701 Tours that I'm gaming now. IMO the AP2s provide the most foregivness like that seen in GI but maintain a nice look at address like a players club, which of course by classification it is.

Bottom line is that the AP2s will give you the forgiveness you're looking for and also a players club you can grow into....after that endorsement I'll drop in that you could also try the CB2's.

[golfsavvy]

Best advice...

zzyzxx33, on 21 January 2011 - 12:27 AM, said:

If I were you I would find a good club fitter to help. Also take your old clubs with you so you can compare the new clubs too.

[PAYLEE]

golfsavvy, on 21 January 2011 - 04:35 AM, said:

Best advice...

zzyzxx33, on 21 January 2011 - 12:27 AM, said:

If I were you I would find a good club fitter to help. Also take your old clubs with you so you can compare the new clubs too.

+2, especially if you're about to drop $600-$1000 on a new set of irons.

This is why my bag looks like a hodge-podge of different clubs. It's an intersting exercise to go into a fitting with an open mind and end up with clubs that you probably would have never considered.

[MattMo]

Alot of love for Mizuno's here.  Never tried them, but always wanted to.  Never had to because I've played PING for over 10 years and been very happy.  If you're looking for brand new irons, try the G15's and I15's, maybe the S56's.  If you're looking for used, try the S57, G10's and I5's.  Great deals to be had.  Good luck.

[mkay]

At your age and handicap, I would go with something that has the chance of improving your ballstriking and which doesn't play as game improvement. I would definately go with a players club of sorts, a few has been mentioned, like Mizuno mp63,68,62,53 etc. Or Titleist 710 CBs, AP2's,  Ping S56.

Or maybe wait and check out the new TM lineup.

And ofc there is also the nike lineup, which are supposed to be nice as well.

I am playing around 8-10 as well, im no longhitter but my shortgame is pretty good, and I will most likely go in the direction of mizuno mp63,53 or maybe the JPX800's just because I could use some extra distance from the irons from time to time . (yes I am indeed a mizuno fanboy). But I won't rule out anything else that feels good and that I can hit well.

So like others say, get fit, keep an open mind to the different brands and offerings.

Good hunting

Edited by mkay, 21 January 2011 - 01:20 PM.

[bwgolf]

If you get a chance, try a set of I15's.  I've had a set for over a year now and really like the feel and setup of these clubs.  The 3, 4 and 5 irons are easy to hit, long and workable.  I've tried other brands, but always seem to come back to Ping, just my personal preference.  Try to get to demo events, hit as many clubs as possible (off grass) and go with what feels best for you.   Good luck

[Titclemiz]

Buy a set that fits you, treat them well, and don't become a club ho.

[Swingfly]

phillyj23, on 20 January 2011 - 12:36 PM, said:

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

How well do you hit your irons? The handicap says nothing about how good you are with your irons, get fitted and, and have fun!

[KoKo2]

phillyj23, on 20 January 2011 - 12:36 PM, said:

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

Why are you a 10 handicap?  Are you a good ball striker and struggle with the short game or vice versa?  Reason being is that it can make a difference with what irons you go with...for instance I am a 7 handicap but until recently ball striking was my weakness as while playing to an 8.5 handicap I continued to try and play blades and player irons.  Well about 2 months ago I decided to give GI irons a try and went through a long process of testing irons and decided to go with the Titleist AP1 irons.  My handicap has already dropped one (which once in the single digits it can move slowly) and my stats do not lie as I am hitting more greens and my misses are much more forgiviing...so with all that said my advice is to go with a GI iron (like the AP1) and keep working on your game unless you are a very solid ball striker...forget the hype of what is in your bag because there are no pictures on the scorecard...

[ladahl]

Mizzy mx-300's can be found brand-new from golfsmith.com for 599

[srvfan]

AP1's are a great choice.  Buy the original not the 710s used...plenty out there at a good price.   Stock TT high launch shafts and you will love them.  I have not met anyone who has played these clubs who has a negative word about them.  Forgiving, easy to hit.  Very safe bet buying these clubs.  Guarantee it.

[jwood2413]

I play to around a 10 handicap (havent kept up with it in a while) and Im 19 yrs old. I went from Nike VR Full Cavities, went from around a 15 down to the 10 with them over the summer playing 4 times a week. Found a great deal on VR Split Cavs and sold my full cavs. Now with school I don't play as much and my swing is a bit inconsistent. I regretted selling the full cavs so I just bought another set today after trying the new VR Pro Cavities and how easy the were to hit at a demo day and thinking they arent much different than the full cavs but way more expensive. But anyways like a guy said here already it doesnt matter what your handicap is but just what type of iron player you are. Both of the sets I mentioned are amazing IMO.

[Chew70]

I am a 10 handicap and play mp-68's. I was a 10 handicap with 09 burners as well so don't let anyone talk you out of blades if you like them. Play with what you like to look at and what feels the best to you. It is your money. Do get fit for whatever you decide.

[ceasterb]

echelon2011, on 20 January 2011 - 01:28 PM, said:

phillyj23, on 20 January 2011 - 12:36 PM, said:

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

Have a look at Mizuno MX300. Mizuno MP53, Mizuno MP58 and Mizuno MP63.

Do not, And I really must stress this, buy a set of irons before you hit the Mizunos.

It's a huge difference between cast and forged clubs, but an equally large difference between properly forged clubs and clubs that are basicly cast and then pounded once in a machine.

You can't go wrong with Mizunos.  Maybe try a combo set of 53s (3-6) and 63s (PW-7).  Also, the Titleist 710 AP2s are a great way to go and they may be a bit more forgiving.

Edited by ceasterb, 08 February 2011 - 05:12 AM.

[ladahl]

ceasterb, on 08 February 2011 - 05:11 AM, said:

echelon2011, on 20 January 2011 - 01:28 PM, said:

phillyj23, on 20 January 2011 - 12:36 PM, said:

Im 18 years old and play at a 10 handicap.  Any ideas for a set of irons?

Have a look at Mizuno MX300. Mizuno MP53, Mizuno MP58 and Mizuno MP63.

Do not, And I really must stress this, buy a set of irons before you hit the Mizunos.

It's a huge difference between cast and forged clubs, but an equally large difference between properly forged clubs and clubs that are basicly cast and then pounded once in a machine.

You can't go wrong with Mizunos.  Maybe try a combo set of 53s (3-6) and 63s (PW-7).  Also, the Titleist 710 AP2s are a great way to go and they may be a bit more forgiving.

MX-300's can be had for a great price right now....  The MX-800 pros are the "newer" one.  Tour guys are even playing these (just enough forgiveness)....

Witht he 800 pros, you could have them fitted to your exact specs (L,L,L, shaft) , and they can be purcahsed "ala cart" so you could create your perfect set-up... Or you could order them 4-9, and dropin 47, 52, 56, 60 wedges of your favorite maker....