Since everyone online is scratch, where do they all play??? Curious
#1
Posted 30 September 2008 - 10:48 AM
Now with those stats and my hcp i am most of the time one of the better players in my group and one of the longer ones off the tee and i dont hit it far. So was curious where do all you guys play or do other people see this false claims. Im sure there are a good amount of people here who are very good but this many. The pros dont even have stats like most of the people on here claim. Guess there is really no point to this post, just curious and venting abit.
#2
Posted 30 September 2008 - 10:58 AM
Personally, i haven't had a handicap since i was in high school. I would assume i'm somewhere around a 5, i'm 20 years old and a Professional Golf Management student at Methodist University. I would say i carry the ball 250-260 and it rolls out to 270. I play at the course we have on campus, The Members Club at Methodist University, as well as local courses like Pinehurst and Pine Needles when time allows.
#3
Posted 30 September 2008 - 11:00 AM
I'm guessing on a forum, about golf, you get people that are more fired up about the game than the norm.
Maybe they learn, practice and play more than the average joe...? Maybe they just have more time. Hard sayin not knowin. But I think you have a funny and good point.
Turns out Im a 2, lol. Seriously.
#6
Posted 30 September 2008 - 11:28 AM
#8
Posted 30 September 2008 - 11:36 AM
#9
Posted 30 September 2008 - 12:01 PM
NOT what you want to do. trust me on this one.
#10
Posted 30 September 2008 - 12:04 PM
jchez444, on Sep 30 2008, 11:48 AM, said:
Now with those stats and my hcp i am most of the time one of the better players in my group and one of the longer ones off the tee and i dont hit it far. So was curious where do all you guys play or do other people see this false claims. Im sure there are a good amount of people here who are very good but this many. The pros dont even have stats like most of the people on here claim. Guess there is really no point to this post, just curious and venting abit.
Welcome to the MATRIX.
The #1 rule in here is that "Do not believe anyone until you see for yourself".
#14
Posted 30 September 2008 - 12:31 PM
Personally, I have never been one to practice much, I rarely chip or putt unless I'm warming up before a tee time(which is unusual as well). My driver swing speed is around 110 and I carry my drives in the 260-265 range with about 20 yards of roll out on average. I have a very good iron game and can basically get up and down from anywhere.
I don't get bogged down with the technical details of the golf swing and never have. I have only had two lessons in my life both coming within the first year of playing. I honestly don't know much about the swing and can't tell anyone how to do it or what they may be doing wrong. Its always just came really easy for me.
I've played a few tournaments on the Hooters tour a few years ago with not much success. I mainly play for fun and side game bets these days. I play the occasional local tournament and normally do well.
As for the members here, I think GolfWRX just happens to attract the serious golfers that are out there. I have played with quite a few of the members here at different times and courses over the last couple of years and have yet to see a player that misrepresented their ability, that includes scoring and distances they hit the ball.
#15
Posted 30 September 2008 - 12:35 PM
I think the 2nd post says it all, we are all different on here
I'm a little obsessive about the game and thats why i'm here. I play off 12 can hit the ball 250+ with the driver. But my dad only hits the same distance as my 4 iron yet beats me all the time. My short game isn't as good as it should be for my ball striking ability and thats why I play off 12 and not 6 I suppose.
A classic example of my ok swing, but with a bad short game
#16
Posted 30 September 2008 - 12:49 PM
Then join this thing:
http://www.thegolfch...hedules.asp?ID=
it's for Amateurs. In other words, no Prize Money. You are put into the Flight according to your handicap, and play against people of your skill level = but, you get to act as if you're on a Pro Tour someplace, in that sort of atmosphere - and there, you will get to see some good players who are single handicaps. But the Tour plays with proper USGA rules, and in the group you're all repsonsible for keeping track = and if you hand in the wrong scorecard, you are DQed.
Try it.
#17
Posted 30 September 2008 - 01:08 PM
#18
Posted 30 September 2008 - 01:10 PM
That aside, I see lots of players on here who claim relatively modest handicaps and playing abilities and many more who quite happily claim high or mid-range handicaps. Yes, there are a few who swing a driver at 120mph and hit it 300, but there are more than a few of those out there anyway if you get out and play with some better players - or at least people who aren't your regular fourball. Forums like this one are a natural habitat for people who are keen or serious players and to see a lot of low-handicappers isn't all that unbelievable.
For me, my numbers are fairly modest for my level of play: I swing, as far as I know, at around 110-112mph with a driver, carry my driver about 260 yards and hit a 7 iron about 165. Nothing earth shattering and usually enough to see me being outdriven probably half the time when I play with players of a similar standard. I currently play to a 1 handicap in the UK and have played scratch or thereabouts golf since 1989 when I was 15. At my best I played off +1.4; at my worst I went up to 3 when I came back from a layoff from the game through health issues. I've always been a solid ballstriker and have a decent tee to green game based on hitting a lot of fairways and GIRs. My short game is solid, and I am a notoriously streaky putter who generally makes very little but occasionally makes everything I look at. In my time I've had at least a share of four amateur course records when I got a warm putter.
I toyed with the idea of turning pro in my late teens but settled on remaining an amateur and have played amateur golf at various levels from club up to national level albeit without winning anything really big in the amateur game. I struggle to find much time to play these days owing to work and family commitments, but for many years played at least some golf almost every day and played consistently to a decent standard. Nowadays I play mainly casual golf and struggle to practice as much as I'd like to in order to remain consistent. My scores this year have ranged between high 60s through to a couple around the 80 mark and, if I'm honest, I've got little interest in playing competitively again on any sort of regular basis. These days, I'm happy to just be 'one of the decent players' at my home club, without ambitions of anything much more, and to tinker with clubs in the garage. If you're looking for other-worldly clubhead speeds or carry distances, you'd better look elsewhere.
No offence, but these 'I call BS' type threads come up on a regular basis and tend to be written by someone of a modest (albeit, playing off 14, you're better than average) standard with limited experience of playing with anyone other than a regular group of mid-handicappers. Get out and play with different people a bit more and you'll see there really are some decent players out there - a lot of whom are attracted by sites like this one. No doubt there are some internet pros on here, but there are also a lot of genuinely decent players who don't see a need to exaggerate their ability or driving distances.
Regardless of real or imagined ability, there are dozens of members on here who provide informative and entertaining opinions on a variety of subjects.
#19
Posted 30 September 2008 - 01:22 PM
All of that to say this. i think I suck at golf. i hit some of the worst shots the world has ever seen. Its hard to imagine bragging about being able to hit the ball that far and still shooting in the 80s, but I'm sure there are people that do that. My point is, the same as many people have already posted, there are plenty of people on this forum I'm sure that are just like me. We are on a golf forum because we are a bit fanatical about it. I would expect us to be, on average, better than average
#20
Posted 30 September 2008 - 01:37 PM
mat562, on Sep 30 2008, 02:10 PM, said:
Regardless of real or imagined ability, there are dozens of members on here who provide informative and entertaining opinions on a variety of subjects.
Spot on as usual. My regular group features guys that all have swingspeeds in excess of 110, the highest being me at about 120. I also have the highest handicap (read worst), a 3.4 at last check. I've been down to scratch before, for about a year when I was playing several times a week and practicing as much. Now I play about once a week and hit balls once a week typically. I'm capable right now of anything from a 70 to an 85, typically high 70's low 80's depending on how many putts I hole. No need to exaggerate...geez why on earth would I. If you're ever in Hickory NC, I'm the lefty flying it out of the back of the driving range, with the red and blue rocket tour driver headcover. Stop in and say hi. If you've got any tips for better iron shots, I'll be happy to listen...hahhaa.
#22
Posted 30 September 2008 - 02:39 PM
mat562, on Sep 30 2008, 02:10 PM, said:
No offense either, but how could you possibly know whether a poster plays in a regular group or not. In this case he stated that he plays as a single a lot of the time and gets matched up with other players.
In any case, I think it's a legitimate question. The OP isn't calling anyone a liar, he's just wondering where they play. I've often wondered the same thing. I've been playing for 20 years and get paired up with others almost every time I play on weekends and in various leagues. In all that time I can remember playing with one person who legitimately hit the ball 300 yards. I can't remember ever playing with anyone who shot par or better. Obviously these players do exist, that's not in question, maybe they all belong to private clubs?
#24
Posted 30 September 2008 - 02:52 PM
krustyburger, on Sep 30 2008, 03:39 PM, said:
I've only ever been randomly paired up with a truly good player (this guy was scratch for sure) golfer one time. I've played probably more than half of my total rounds as a single.
#25
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:00 PM
mat562, on Sep 30 2008, 01:10 PM, said:
That aside, I see lots of players on here who claim relatively modest handicaps and playing abilities and many more who quite happily claim high or mid-range handicaps. Yes, there are a few who swing a driver at 120mph and hit it 300, but there are more than a few of those out there anyway if you get out and play with some better players - or at least people who aren't your regular fourball. Forums like this one are a natural habitat for people who are keen or serious players and to see a lot of low-handicappers isn't all that unbelievable.
For me, my numbers are fairly modest for my level of play: I swing, as far as I know, at around 110-112mph with a driver, carry my driver about 260 yards and hit a 7 iron about 165. Nothing earth shattering and usually enough to see me being outdriven probably half the time when I play with players of a similar standard. I currently play to a 1 handicap in the UK and have played scratch or thereabouts golf since 1989 when I was 15. At my best I played off +1.4; at my worst I went up to 3 when I came back from a layoff from the game through health issues. I've always been a solid ballstriker and have a decent tee to green game based on hitting a lot of fairways and GIRs. My short game is solid, and I am a notoriously streaky putter who generally makes very little but occasionally makes everything I look at. In my time I've had at least a share of four amateur course records when I got a warm putter.
I toyed with the idea of turning pro in my late teens but settled on remaining an amateur and have played amateur golf at various levels from club up to national level albeit without winning anything really big in the amateur game. I struggle to find much time to play these days owing to work and family commitments, but for many years played at least some golf almost every day and played consistently to a decent standard. Nowadays I play mainly casual golf and struggle to practice as much as I'd like to in order to remain consistent. My scores this year have ranged between high 60s through to a couple around the 80 mark and, if I'm honest, I've got little interest in playing competitively again on any sort of regular basis. These days, I'm happy to just be 'one of the decent players' at my home club, without ambitions of anything much more, and to tinker with clubs in the garage. If you're looking for other-worldly clubhead speeds or carry distances, you'd better look elsewhere.
No offence, but these 'I call BS' type threads come up on a regular basis and tend to be written by someone of a modest (albeit, playing off 14, you're better than average) standard with limited experience of playing with anyone other than a regular group of mid-handicappers. Get out and play with different people a bit more and you'll see there really are some decent players out there - a lot of whom are attracted by sites like this one. No doubt there are some internet pros on here, but there are also a lot of genuinely decent players who don't see a need to exaggerate their ability or driving distances.
Regardless of real or imagined ability, there are dozens of members on here who provide informative and entertaining opinions on a variety of subjects.
They are impressive stats Mat, especially as you seem to have kept it consistant for sooo long
#26
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:03 PM
Money is changing hands, so rest assured, if I could have more strokes, I would.
I've played several stroke play tournaments this summer, including my state senior championship, and rest assured, there are players everywhere who drive it long, hit irons, chip and putt.
Play more events - even if it's just a scramble - and you'll quickly see how many hundreds of very good players there are in your area.
#27
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:23 PM
#29
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:36 PM
There is no doubt that there is some bull-s*** floating about, it happens with any sport. Make no mistake though, there are people out there that can flat-out play, or put a level of hurt on the ball that you cannot comprehend.
I have the experience of playing with alot of the better players my age at my club, and building clubs for them. A number of them are turning pro, and are great fun to play with and help where possible.
I may not be awesome at golf, but I enjoy playing(i wouldn't say I'm bad, and I can poke it out to 270-280). My passion is building and tweaking clubs, experimenting and using my experience with clubs to help other players set up their clubs. At a small price
#30
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:43 PM
Ackerman Hills - 6433 yards - 71.1/126
Kampen Course - 7465 yards - 76.5/143
Handicap: +1.7
I like to play Kampen the most and that is where ours tournaments are held, but it's kind of nice to play Ackerman Hills walking in the same place as Jack Nicklaus when he won an NCAA Champtionship.
#31
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:45 PM
Don't come on to a board and insult a entire group!
#32
Posted 30 September 2008 - 03:45 PM
I've played with both kinds.
Some people accept their ability and don't reason away half of their strokes b/c they don't
"usually play like this."
Some people are actually very good.
#33
Posted 30 September 2008 - 04:09 PM
I completely agree with the OP. I read on here how guys are so good and long and I am sure there are. Yet when I go play I rarely see it. I think there are more concetrated good players here because if you are a member here you are more die hard then most. I play on Saturday mornings in a stableford format (2 pts for par, 4 for birdie, 1 for bogey, 0 for double). I like playing this format because your points adjust every week and its harder to sandbag. We also play for skins. I only like playing for money, or if money is involved. (Otherwise I am starting to play every other Sunday with my 14 year old son who is beginning to play more seriously.) I have to pull 43 points to break even on one course and 38 on a harder course. Low rounds this year have been a 64 on the easier course and 65 on the harder course (this was the qualifiing score for the local PGA event when held at this course). I have got to the point in life where I care less about how far I hit the ball compared to how accurate. That is more important, just after your short game, My driving is by far the worst part of my game. The problem with guys that hit the ball 280-300 is if you are 5 yards off you are 20 yards in the woods. Compared to someone that hits it 230 five yards off line, they are still in play. I had that discussion with another player who actually drove past me 10-20 yards and he completely agreed, and hit 5 wood most of the round. So being long is good, yet brings in much more trouble. I actually love when guys tell me they can do this and that, drive the ball 300, That is when the wallet comes out.....
actually I take that all back, if you or a golfing friend are ever in the Tampa Florida area, I am a 12 hcp and would like to play for some cash... Haha
#34
Posted 30 September 2008 - 04:19 PM
I don't keep a handicap, but I do swing at about 112 mph and I don't hit it all that far because of a wicked "fade" (slice) that has been plagging me.
Got paired up with a guy today that was blowing it by me by atleast 30-35 yards on some holes and I hit it atleast 250. He was all carry, I had some roll.
I surmise the better players are playing the better public courses in the area and working/ playing at private courses.
#36
Posted 30 September 2008 - 04:42 PM
jchez444, on Sep 30 2008, 11:48 AM, said:
Now with those stats and my hcp i am most of the time one of the better players in my group and one of the longer ones off the tee and i dont hit it far. So was curious where do all you guys play or do other people see this false claims. Im sure there are a good amount of people here who are very good but this many. The pros dont even have stats like most of the people on here claim. Guess there is really no point to this post, just curious and venting abit.
I just finished my senior year of college golf and I'm now playing mostly NCGA events. I've seen plenty of people with a 120 mph ss who fly it 270+ and can back the ball up a ton, which is usually an undesired result of a fast swing and clean contact. At my last tournament there were a few guys with a +4 index & one of them shot a 58 and blew away the field. I'm sure there are plenty of guys here with a vanity handicap, but there are also a lot of guys here who have legitimate plus handicaps. If you're ever in the SF bay area send me a pm, I'll take you to a skins game with some of the sites longer members.
#37
Posted 30 September 2008 - 05:25 PM
Boba, on Sep 30 2008, 04:42 PM, said:
jchez444, on Sep 30 2008, 11:48 AM, said:
Now with those stats and my hcp i am most of the time one of the better players in my group and one of the longer ones off the tee and i dont hit it far. So was curious where do all you guys play or do other people see this false claims. Im sure there are a good amount of people here who are very good but this many. The pros dont even have stats like most of the people on here claim. Guess there is really no point to this post, just curious and venting abit.
I just finished my senior year of college golf and I'm now playing mostly NCGA events. I've seen plenty of people with a 120 mph ss who fly it 270+ and can back the ball up a ton, which is usually an undesired result of a fast swing and clean contact. At my last tournament there were a few guys with a +4 index & one of them shot a 58 and blew away the field. I'm sure there are plenty of guys here with a vanity handicap, but there are also a lot of guys here who have legitimate plus handicaps. If you're ever in the SF bay area send me a pm, I'll take you to a skins game with some of the sites longer members.
58???
#38
Posted 30 September 2008 - 05:26 PM
When you look at the people on here and their WITB sigs and handicaps and whatever, sure you dont really see them down your local club every week but you do come across the odd one or two, but then think of how big this planet is, were pretty spread out...
Ive played with people literatly playing their first round of golf, to mid handicappers, low handicappers, club pros, tour pros and at the end of the day the level of play is part of the game for sure, but were all the same, were just people going out and hitting a ball and enjoying the social side of it... Its no different playing with some one fantastic to someone who chops it round, you still probably talk about money, fast cars, girls, clubs, TV, music, whatever, just that the good player hits the ball a little better and gets it in the hole quicker...
#39
Posted 30 September 2008 - 05:26 PM
I also fill in with a group of outstanding golfers and even if I was to fire off a 75-77 I am still getting smoked but they all belong to the same private club and that is where they play 90% of thier rounds.
Is there bs out there sure there is. The male ego can be a fragile thing. I would venture out and say the majority on what the members post in regards to their handicap is legit (I cant speak for the whats your 200yard club thread though
Maybe its just me that thinks like this, but I think alot of people may end up feeling mediocre about their long game when they read about these guys b*tching about a 280 yard mishit. If you spend all your time worrying about what other people are doing how is your game going to improve??????????????
One other thing to consider is this excerpt from golf digest's "what is a 10 handicap" article around the time of the us open
Quote
Men with an Index of 10.0 or better are in the upper 25 percent of all golfers. Players with a 10.0 comprise 4.6 percent of the golf population. The national average Handicap Index for men is 14.7, approximately one stroke lower than it was in 1990, when the USGA began tracking Golf Handicap and Information Network (GHIN) trends. Although golf courses in general are longer and more difficult, a 10-handicapper is better because of improved instruction and advances in equipment.
thats all gotta go back to work on the putt putt game new club championship coming up
#40
Posted 30 September 2008 - 06:25 PM
jchez444, on Sep 30 2008, 08:48 AM, said:
Now with those stats and my hcp i am most of the time one of the better players in my group and one of the longer ones off the tee and i dont hit it far. So was curious where do all you guys play or do other people see this false claims. Im sure there are a good amount of people here who are very good but this many. The pros dont even have stats like most of the people on here claim. Guess there is really no point to this post, just curious and venting abit.
Hmm.....maybe you are looking at a different site then golfwrx.com? For real, I would have to say that if you get enough people that are sitting around on their computers reading about golf, that should tell you how devoted to golf they really are! Your post seems disrepectful at best. Golf for probably everyone on this board is not just a sport or a hobbie to fill the year - its a lifestyle. We love golf, we love writing about it, watching it and reading about it. I'm sure there are grown men who have stood on the first tee of a great course (St. Andrews, Pebble,Bandon) and have been choked up because its the realization of a dream to play there. Those are the same grown men I've seen bomb it down the fairway 275 yards or back it up on the green like a PGA pro. Its because golf, at least for some, is taken seriously and shown the respect it deserves. There is no other game like it.





Sign In
Register
Help

Quote
























