Jump to content

Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at GolfWRX such as viewing all the images, interacting with members, access to all forums and eligiblility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE GolfWRX account here.

- - - - -

Trackman Fitting Results (718, MP18, Epic Pro, iBlade, PXG)


  • Please log in to reply
15 replies to this topic

#1 TNReb

TNReb

    Tour Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 611 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 206233
  • Joined: 10/08/2012
  • Location:Tennessee
  • Handicap:2
GolfWRX Likes : 117

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:16 AM

If anyone wants a reference, here's a bit about me...

36 years old
1 handicap when I'm playing my best (0.4 currently - lowest I've ever been).
3 handicap when I'm not.
I play 95% of my rounds at the same course.  My home course doesn't require a lot of full iron shots, so 6 and 7 irons are not the strength of my game.  
I probably play 75 rounds a year.

----

With that being said...

Yesterday I spent some time working with Curtis Leggett at Sea Island Performance Center.

https://www.seaislan...r/club-fitting/

It's a 20 hour round trip drive for me, but this is the 4th time I have been.  I have worked with Craig Allan twice before, and this was my second time working with Curtis.  Both guys are fantastic.  I wouldn't be making such a long trip if I didn't believe they were some of the best in the nation at what they do.  To me, buying a set of irons is a pretty big investment and I want to know that I'm working with guys who really know their stuff.  Curtis works with Davis Love III and Zach Johnson - I just hit balls and hope I don't scare him off.

I was there to be fitted for a new set of irons.
My current irons are 716 AP2 with Nippon Modus3 Tour 130 shafts.

I told Curtis I had a few irons in mind that I wanted to try - the 718 MB & CB and the Mizuno MP 18 & SC.
I told him to just hand me clubs and don't tell me anything about the shafts.  I didn't want any preconceived notions of mine affecting anything.

Right away we found that we were chasing my 716 AP2 spin numbers.  Everything else I tried was spinning considerably more.

In the chart below, you can see Mizuno still does their fittings with 6 irons, so you can't really compare apples to oranges.  

[attachment=4150554:TrackMan.JPG]

General thoughts...

I've never been a fan of the feel of KBS shafts.  I love the feel of my Nippon 130 - but have never tried any other Nippon shafts.
Titleist and Mizuno had not sent them the Nippon shafts yet - which was sort of aggravating - but not Sea Island's fault.

The comments below are in the order that I tested the clubs.

I didn't put it in the chart, but average attack angle was -7.7.

Titleist 718 AP3 - These were the first irons Curtis recommended because they're generally a lower spinning head and he knew the CB and MB would spin a lot for me.  He was right - they had less spin than most other irons we tried.  I just didn't like the look of these.  They are larger than my 716 AP2 and I don't like clubs that are real big.  This was in my head and I simply didn't make solid contact with them.  I hit it lower and lost yardage due to toe shots, fat shots, etc.  Bad swings = bad results.  


Titleist 718 CB - Before the AP2 irons, I played a set of MB/CB combos.  I was familiar with this club look and it suits my eye.  However, I simply couldn't put a very good swing on the ball.  I had a little nerves at first - pressure to hit good shots.  I hit the ball much higher with these and lost distance.  


Titleist 718 MB - Curtis said these would spin too much, and he was right.  I was starting to loosen up and my swing speed was increasing a little bit.  The KBS Tour felt ok to me - it actually felt like some of the smoothest shots I hit all day.  However, the spin was too high and the peak ball height was a good bit higher.  Despite the fact that the shots felt smooth, the smash factor was down from my AP2 and the ball speed wasn't there.  The C-Taper shafts felt rough to me.  I didn't like their look and made bad swings.


Mizuno MP18 Blade - Note - this is where I was testing with a 6 irons.  The Mizuno were standard lie, which is about 1-2 degrees flatter than I prefer.  This was bothering me.  I couldn't make solid contact and we didn't spend much time here.  I liked the look of the club - but it was pretty quickly obvious that they were not going to be optimal for me.  


Mizuno MP18 SC - Also a 6 iron.  Lower spinning than the blade, but ball contact was still poor and we moved on.


Ping iBlade - I've never played Ping irons, so the look was a little different than I'm used to.  They felt good - but the spin was still too high.  Moving on...


Callaway Epic Pro - These clubs were different than anything I'm used to.  The top lines seemed thicker (similar to the AP3) and they felt a little clicky.  To me, feel is influenced by sound and these had a different sound than a forged Titleist or Mizuno.  However, the numbers were better.  Spin was a little lower and my smash factor was back where it should be.  I was glad to finally get to try a Nippon shaft - and I liked the feel of it. It just felt smoother for my swing than the KBS shafts.  When it was all said and done, these were the ones Curtis recommended.  


PXG 0311T - These clubs fit my eye.  The offset, top-line, everything. The clubs felt pretty smooth to me with the Nippon shaft.  Ball speed was nearly identical to my AP2.  The spin was still on the high side.  This cost me about 2.5 yards carry distance.  The KBS Tour V shaft had less spin but didn't feel as smooth - I felt like I had to work harder to feel the shaft kick/load and this resluted in worse swings with slighly slower ball speeds.



Final Thoughts...

I stopped at the PGA Superstore in Atlanta on the way home to look at the entire set of Callaway Epic Pros.  No bueno.  I simply didn't like the look of the set.  Too "big" for my eye.  

The PXG 0311T and the Titleist MB/CB fit my eye the best.  I really wonder what the MB/CB would do with the Nippon 120 shaft.  
I also wonder if the PXG with Nippon 120 shaft is playable, or if I would find too much spin in playing conditions.  I am tempted to pull the trigger on them because they provided respectable numbers and fit my eye best.  

In the end, my 716 AP2 and very playable and nothing really beat them.  I'm simply not crazy about the look of the shorter irons.  I don't carry the AP2 pitching wedge - and the 8 & 9 irons feel like they have no "precision".  



Pardon my rambling... hopefully someone will find this helpful.

Edited by TNReb, 12 October 2017 - 10:22 AM.


Remove This Advertisement Viewing As Guest

    GolfWRX Forums

    Advertisement


1

#2 Underdog1924

Underdog1924

    Advanced

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 300 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 197782
  • Joined: 08/12/2012
  • Ebay ID:underdog_19
GolfWRX Likes : 20

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:40 AM

Any chance to hit the 718 AP2?  Going from the 716s to 718 might be the best of both worlds.
2016 TM M2 w/ Fubuki J
Titleist 915F 15* w/ Project X 7C3
Titleist 906F4 18* w/ Aldila NV
Titleist 910H 21* w/ Project X HD2
Titleist T-MB 4 w/ Recoil F4
Titleist 712 AP2 5-9 w/ Dynamic Gold AMT S300
Titleist Vokey 46*F, 52*F & 58* TVD-K Low Bounce w/ DG S200
Scotty Cameron Laguna 1.5

2

#3 cliffhanger

cliffhanger

    Major Winner

  • ClubWRX Charter Members
  • 1,356 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 133399
  • Joined: 07/18/2011
  • Location:spruce grove alberta
  • Handicap:10.5
GolfWRX Likes : 697

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:45 AM

Are these numbers the best shot of each or do they represent an average? If they are an average... how many shots do they represent? I would think in this case... a more apples to apples comparison would be all with the same shaft, flex, length, lie. Even still... nice write up.
new driver coming
new 3 wood coming
new 5 wood coming
Mizuno MP 18 Fly Hi 3 iron with Project X LZ 6.0 1deg flat
MP 18 blades 4-PW with PX LZ 6.0 1 deg flat
Mizuno T7 50 and 54 degree wedges with PX LZ 6.0 2 deg flat
Bettinardi studio stock #3 counterbalanced at 36 inches
testing new balls

3

#4 TNReb

TNReb

    Tour Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 611 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 206233
  • Joined: 10/08/2012
  • Location:Tennessee
  • Handicap:2
GolfWRX Likes : 117

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:48 AM

View PostUnderdog1924, on 12 October 2017 - 10:40 AM, said:

Any chance to hit the 718 AP2?  Going from the 716s to 718 might be the best of both worlds.

Didn't even try them.

4

#5 TNReb

TNReb

    Tour Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 611 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 206233
  • Joined: 10/08/2012
  • Location:Tennessee
  • Handicap:2
GolfWRX Likes : 117

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:51 AM

View Postcliffhanger, on 12 October 2017 - 10:45 AM, said:

Are these numbers the best shot of each or do they represent an average? If they are an average... how many shots do they represent? I would think in this case... a more apples to apples comparison would be all with the same shaft, flex, length, lie. Even still... nice write up.

These are an average of "normal shots" - with real bad ones thrown out (complete chunks, really thin shots, etc).  There's probably about 5-8 shots in each group.

You are correct that a more apples-to-apples comparison would be same shaft, flex, length, lie, etc - but this was a fitting session - trying to find what works with the equipment the manufacturers send to the fitters.


5

#6 cliffhanger

cliffhanger

    Major Winner

  • ClubWRX Charter Members
  • 1,356 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 133399
  • Joined: 07/18/2011
  • Location:spruce grove alberta
  • Handicap:10.5
GolfWRX Likes : 697

Posted 12 October 2017 - 10:55 AM

View PostTNReb, on 12 October 2017 - 10:51 AM, said:

View Postcliffhanger, on 12 October 2017 - 10:45 AM, said:

Are these numbers the best shot of each or do they represent an average? If they are an average... how many shots do they represent? I would think in this case... a more apples to apples comparison would be all with the same shaft, flex, length, lie. Even still... nice write up.

These are an average of "normal shots" - with real bad ones thrown out (complete chunks, really thin shots, etc).  There's probably about 5-8 shots in each group.

You are correct that a more apples-to-apples comparison would be same shaft, flex, length, lie, etc - but this was a fitting session - trying to find what works with the equipment the manufacturers send to the fitters.
I would bet it will be hard to get away from the Modus 130x... too bad that shaft and flex will be very hard to find in most if not all fitting carts.
new driver coming
new 3 wood coming
new 5 wood coming
Mizuno MP 18 Fly Hi 3 iron with Project X LZ 6.0 1deg flat
MP 18 blades 4-PW with PX LZ 6.0 1 deg flat
Mizuno T7 50 and 54 degree wedges with PX LZ 6.0 2 deg flat
Bettinardi studio stock #3 counterbalanced at 36 inches
testing new balls

6

#7 jcg132

jcg132

    PTPOTCW

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 433 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 428230
  • Joined: 06/07/2016
  • Location:Stamford, CT
  • Ebay ID:jcg132
GolfWRX Likes : 119

Posted 12 October 2017 - 01:04 PM

Fwiw, I game the 0311Ts with Modus 120S. Really like them. Definitely lost a few yards over my previous set up (Apexs with TT Dynalite Gold XP bent 2* strong), but am hitting and holding more greens. Feel is fantastic also.
Tour Issue Callaway GBB Epic Sub Zero "L Stamp" 8° - Aldila SYNERGY Black Graphene Tour PROTO 65 TX (44.5")
Callaway Rogue 15° -
Mitsubishi Chemical TENSEI CK Pro White 70 Stiff (42.75", Tipped 0.5", 1.0° Flat, D6)
Callaway Rogue Hybrid 19° - VA Composites Raijin Hybrid 84 Four (Tipped, 0.5", D4)
Callaway Epic 22° -
Mitsubishi Chemical TENSEI CK Pro White Hybrid 90 TX (Tipped 0.5", D4)
PXG 0311 5-7 - Nippon N.S. PRO Modus3 Tour 120 Stiff (+0.5", 2.0° Upright, D4)

PXG 0311T 8-PW - Nippon N.S. PRO Modus3 Tour 120 Stiff (+0.5", 1.0° Strong, 2.0° Upright)
Vokey SM6 Raw 50.08°F - Nippon N.S. PRO Modus3 Tour 120 Stiff (+0.5", 1.0° Upright)
Vokey SM6 Raw 55.09°S - Nippon N.S. PRO Modus3 Tour 120 Stiff (+0.5", 1.0° Upright)
Vokey SM6 Raw 60.08°M - Nippon N.S. PRO Modus3 Tour 120 Stiff (+0.5", 1.0° Upright)
Scotty Cameron 009M Carbon - 34", 3.5
°, 70°

Wilson Staff Duo Urethane
Golf Pride MCC Plus4
FootJoy Pure Touch Limited
Sun Mountain 4.5 14-Way
Nike Apparel


Instagram

7

#8 TNReb

TNReb

    Tour Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 611 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 206233
  • Joined: 10/08/2012
  • Location:Tennessee
  • Handicap:2
GolfWRX Likes : 117

Posted 12 October 2017 - 02:49 PM

View Postjcg132, on 12 October 2017 - 01:04 PM, said:

Fwiw, I game the 0311Ts with Modus 120S. Really like them. Definitely lost a few yards over my previous set up (Apexs with TT Dynalite Gold XP bent 2* strong), but am hitting and holding more greens. Feel is fantastic also.

Thanks for the feedback.

I actually found a local PXG fitter out of a club that's 30 minutes from me.  I emailed him and told him where i lived and asked if he happen to have a set I could stop in and look at.  Turns out he lives 15 minutes from me and he offered to come by my house.  He was nice enough to bring a 4, 7, and PW to my house today and let me hit them (I live on the golf course).  Very cool of him to do that.  

I wasn't warmed up or anything, and I only hit about 10 shots - but the clubs looked good to me.  I was really happy to get to see what the long and short irons look like.

8

#9 NerdyMe

NerdyMe

    Newbie

  • Members
  • Pip
  • 1 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 484210
  • Joined: 10/12/2017
  • Location:California
  • Handicap:10
GolfWRX Likes : 1

Posted 12 October 2017 - 05:15 PM

I'm surprised you didn't like the SC's from Mizuno.

I'm still new to golf, so I'm not 100% sure about the finer points, but from a statistics perspective, it looks like the shaft appears to have had a greater impact on the ball data than the club heads.  Did the different shafts feel as different as the outcome?

Just curious.

I just got through a fitting, and I went with Modus shafts with the MP-18 SC, PW-3 iron.  I don't hit quite as far as you, so maybe the speed has something to do with the feel.  My Carry on a 7 iron is only about 165.

Heck, I haven't broke Eighty yet, so maybe I'm too new to talk about this stuff.

9

#10 jbsg02

jbsg02

    Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 172 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 428788
  • Joined: 06/12/2016
GolfWRX Likes : 60

Posted 12 October 2017 - 05:30 PM

Almost a 100 mph with a 7 iron?  You should be hitting that thing like 190, that's a lot of speed


Remove This Advertisement Viewing As Guest

    GolfWRX Forums

    Advertisement


10

#11 santasquatcha

santasquatcha

    Member

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 155 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 418640
  • Joined: 04/01/2016
  • Location:Detroit
  • Handicap:20+
GolfWRX Likes : 78

Posted 12 October 2017 - 06:58 PM

I play 712CBs with Modus 120S shafts.

Best combo of look at address, sound at impact, and feel with the Nippons.

I agree with you, KBS shafts are very clunky feeling compared to the nippons.

Good luck with finding a new set of clubs, from the fitting data it doesn't look like anything whipped your AP2s to the garage..
Mini-Driver, Taylormade Aeroburner,14*, Matrix 60g S
4h - 5h, Adams Tech V4.0, S
6 - PW, Titleist 712CB, modus120S
GW, 49*, Adams Tech V4.0, S
GW, 51*, Cleveland 588
SW, 56-11*, Titleist Vokey SM4
LW, 60-07*, Titleist Vokey SM4
Putter, Odyssey White Hot #6

11

#12 Wardonation

Wardonation

    Major Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,098 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 107035
  • Joined: 04/28/2010
  • Handicap:+2.8
GolfWRX Likes : 124

Posted 13 October 2017 - 10:05 AM

View PostTNReb, on 12 October 2017 - 10:16 AM, said:

If anyone wants a reference, here's a bit about me...

36 years old
1 handicap when I'm playing my best (0.4 currently - lowest I've ever been).
3 handicap when I'm not.
I play 95% of my rounds at the same course.  My home course doesn't require a lot of full iron shots, so 6 and 7 irons are not the strength of my game.  
I probably play 75 rounds a year.

----

With that being said...

Yesterday I spent some time working with Curtis Leggett at Sea Island Performance Center.

https://www.seaislan...r/club-fitting/

It's a 20 hour round trip drive for me, but this is the 4th time I have been.  I have worked with Craig Allan twice before, and this was my second time working with Curtis.  Both guys are fantastic.  I wouldn't be making such a long trip if I didn't believe they were some of the best in the nation at what they do.  To me, buying a set of irons is a pretty big investment and I want to know that I'm working with guys who really know their stuff.  Curtis works with Davis Love III and Zach Johnson - I just hit balls and hope I don't scare him off.

I was there to be fitted for a new set of irons.
My current irons are 716 AP2 with Nippon Modus3 Tour 130 shafts.

I told Curtis I had a few irons in mind that I wanted to try - the 718 MB & CB and the Mizuno MP 18 & SC.
I told him to just hand me clubs and don't tell me anything about the shafts.  I didn't want any preconceived notions of mine affecting anything.

Right away we found that we were chasing my 716 AP2 spin numbers.  Everything else I tried was spinning considerably more.

In the chart below, you can see Mizuno still does their fittings with 6 irons, so you can't really compare apples to oranges.  

Attachment TrackMan.JPG

General thoughts...

I've never been a fan of the feel of KBS shafts.  I love the feel of my Nippon 130 - but have never tried any other Nippon shafts.
Titleist and Mizuno had not sent them the Nippon shafts yet - which was sort of aggravating - but not Sea Island's fault.

The comments below are in the order that I tested the clubs.

I didn't put it in the chart, but average attack angle was -7.7.

Titleist 718 AP3 - These were the first irons Curtis recommended because they're generally a lower spinning head and he knew the CB and MB would spin a lot for me.  He was right - they had less spin than most other irons we tried.  I just didn't like the look of these.  They are larger than my 716 AP2 and I don't like clubs that are real big.  This was in my head and I simply didn't make solid contact with them.  I hit it lower and lost yardage due to toe shots, fat shots, etc.  Bad swings = bad results.  


Titleist 718 CB - Before the AP2 irons, I played a set of MB/CB combos.  I was familiar with this club look and it suits my eye.  However, I simply couldn't put a very good swing on the ball.  I had a little nerves at first - pressure to hit good shots.  I hit the ball much higher with these and lost distance.  


Titleist 718 MB - Curtis said these would spin too much, and he was right.  I was starting to loosen up and my swing speed was increasing a little bit.  The KBS Tour felt ok to me - it actually felt like some of the smoothest shots I hit all day.  However, the spin was too high and the peak ball height was a good bit higher.  Despite the fact that the shots felt smooth, the smash factor was down from my AP2 and the ball speed wasn't there.  The C-Taper shafts felt rough to me.  I didn't like their look and made bad swings.


Mizuno MP18 Blade - Note - this is where I was testing with a 6 irons.  The Mizuno were standard lie, which is about 1-2 degrees flatter than I prefer.  This was bothering me.  I couldn't make solid contact and we didn't spend much time here.  I liked the look of the club - but it was pretty quickly obvious that they were not going to be optimal for me.  


Mizuno MP18 SC - Also a 6 iron.  Lower spinning than the blade, but ball contact was still poor and we moved on.


Ping iBlade - I've never played Ping irons, so the look was a little different than I'm used to.  They felt good - but the spin was still too high.  Moving on...


Callaway Epic Pro - These clubs were different than anything I'm used to.  The top lines seemed thicker (similar to the AP3) and they felt a little clicky.  To me, feel is influenced by sound and these had a different sound than a forged Titleist or Mizuno.  However, the numbers were better.  Spin was a little lower and my smash factor was back where it should be.  I was glad to finally get to try a Nippon shaft - and I liked the feel of it. It just felt smoother for my swing than the KBS shafts.  When it was all said and done, these were the ones Curtis recommended.  


PXG 0311T - These clubs fit my eye.  The offset, top-line, everything. The clubs felt pretty smooth to me with the Nippon shaft.  Ball speed was nearly identical to my AP2.  The spin was still on the high side.  This cost me about 2.5 yards carry distance.  The KBS Tour V shaft had less spin but didn't feel as smooth - I felt like I had to work harder to feel the shaft kick/load and this resluted in worse swings with slighly slower ball speeds.



Final Thoughts...

I stopped at the PGA Superstore in Atlanta on the way home to look at the entire set of Callaway Epic Pros.  No bueno.  I simply didn't like the look of the set.  Too "big" for my eye.  

The PXG 0311T and the Titleist MB/CB fit my eye the best.  I really wonder what the MB/CB would do with the Nippon 120 shaft.  
I also wonder if the PXG with Nippon 120 shaft is playable, or if I would find too much spin in playing conditions.  I am tempted to pull the trigger on them because they provided respectable numbers and fit my eye best.  

In the end, my 716 AP2 and very playable and nothing really beat them.  I'm simply not crazy about the look of the shorter irons.  I don't carry the AP2 pitching wedge - and the 8 & 9 irons feel like they have no "precision".  



Pardon my rambling... hopefully someone will find this helpful.
I play the PXG T with 120 X ss x1. Great combo... May I ask your driver SS? Mine is 108. I do not spin my combo enough.

12

#13 phatchrisrules

phatchrisrules

    Major Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,350 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 20680
  • Joined: 10/17/2006
  • Location:Southern Ontario, Canada
  • Handicap:6.5
GolfWRX Likes : 429

Posted 14 October 2017 - 09:16 AM

View PostTNReb, on 12 October 2017 - 10:16 AM, said:

If anyone wants a reference, here's a bit about me...

36 years old
1 handicap when I'm playing my best (0.4 currently - lowest I've ever been).
3 handicap when I'm not.
I play 95% of my rounds at the same course.  My home course doesn't require a lot of full iron shots, so 6 and 7 irons are not the strength of my game.  
I probably play 75 rounds a year.

----

With that being said...

Yesterday I spent some time working with Curtis Leggett at Sea Island Performance Center.

https://www.seaislan...r/club-fitting/

It's a 20 hour round trip drive for me, but this is the 4th time I have been.  I have worked with Craig Allan twice before, and this was my second time working with Curtis.  Both guys are fantastic.  I wouldn't be making such a long trip if I didn't believe they were some of the best in the nation at what they do.  To me, buying a set of irons is a pretty big investment and I want to know that I'm working with guys who really know their stuff.  Curtis works with Davis Love III and Zach Johnson - I just hit balls and hope I don't scare him off.

I was there to be fitted for a new set of irons.
My current irons are 716 AP2 with Nippon Modus3 Tour 130 shafts.

I told Curtis I had a few irons in mind that I wanted to try - the 718 MB & CB and the Mizuno MP 18 & SC.
I told him to just hand me clubs and don't tell me anything about the shafts.  I didn't want any preconceived notions of mine affecting anything.

Right away we found that we were chasing my 716 AP2 spin numbers.  Everything else I tried was spinning considerably more.

In the chart below, you can see Mizuno still does their fittings with 6 irons, so you can't really compare apples to oranges.  

Attachment TrackMan.JPG

General thoughts...

I've never been a fan of the feel of KBS shafts.  I love the feel of my Nippon 130 - but have never tried any other Nippon shafts.
Titleist and Mizuno had not sent them the Nippon shafts yet - which was sort of aggravating - but not Sea Island's fault.

The comments below are in the order that I tested the clubs.

I didn't put it in the chart, but average attack angle was -7.7.

Titleist 718 AP3 - These were the first irons Curtis recommended because they're generally a lower spinning head and he knew the CB and MB would spin a lot for me.  He was right - they had less spin than most other irons we tried.  I just didn't like the look of these.  They are larger than my 716 AP2 and I don't like clubs that are real big.  This was in my head and I simply didn't make solid contact with them.  I hit it lower and lost yardage due to toe shots, fat shots, etc.  Bad swings = bad results.  


Titleist 718 CB - Before the AP2 irons, I played a set of MB/CB combos.  I was familiar with this club look and it suits my eye.  However, I simply couldn't put a very good swing on the ball.  I had a little nerves at first - pressure to hit good shots.  I hit the ball much higher with these and lost distance.  


Titleist 718 MB - Curtis said these would spin too much, and he was right.  I was starting to loosen up and my swing speed was increasing a little bit.  The KBS Tour felt ok to me - it actually felt like some of the smoothest shots I hit all day.  However, the spin was too high and the peak ball height was a good bit higher.  Despite the fact that the shots felt smooth, the smash factor was down from my AP2 and the ball speed wasn't there.  The C-Taper shafts felt rough to me.  I didn't like their look and made bad swings.


Mizuno MP18 Blade - Note - this is where I was testing with a 6 irons.  The Mizuno were standard lie, which is about 1-2 degrees flatter than I prefer.  This was bothering me.  I couldn't make solid contact and we didn't spend much time here.  I liked the look of the club - but it was pretty quickly obvious that they were not going to be optimal for me.  


Mizuno MP18 SC - Also a 6 iron.  Lower spinning than the blade, but ball contact was still poor and we moved on.


Ping iBlade - I've never played Ping irons, so the look was a little different than I'm used to.  They felt good - but the spin was still too high.  Moving on...


Callaway Epic Pro - These clubs were different than anything I'm used to.  The top lines seemed thicker (similar to the AP3) and they felt a little clicky.  To me, feel is influenced by sound and these had a different sound than a forged Titleist or Mizuno.  However, the numbers were better.  Spin was a little lower and my smash factor was back where it should be.  I was glad to finally get to try a Nippon shaft - and I liked the feel of it. It just felt smoother for my swing than the KBS shafts.  When it was all said and done, these were the ones Curtis recommended.  


PXG 0311T - These clubs fit my eye.  The offset, top-line, everything. The clubs felt pretty smooth to me with the Nippon shaft.  Ball speed was nearly identical to my AP2.  The spin was still on the high side.  This cost me about 2.5 yards carry distance.  The KBS Tour V shaft had less spin but didn't feel as smooth - I felt like I had to work harder to feel the shaft kick/load and this resluted in worse swings with slighly slower ball speeds.



Final Thoughts...

I stopped at the PGA Superstore in Atlanta on the way home to look at the entire set of Callaway Epic Pros.  No bueno.  I simply didn't like the look of the set.  Too "big" for my eye.  

The PXG 0311T and the Titleist MB/CB fit my eye the best.  I really wonder what the MB/CB would do with the Nippon 120 shaft.  
I also wonder if the PXG with Nippon 120 shaft is playable, or if I would find too much spin in playing conditions.  I am tempted to pull the trigger on them because they provided respectable numbers and fit my eye best.  

In the end, my 716 AP2 and very playable and nothing really beat them.  I'm simply not crazy about the look of the shorter irons.  I don't carry the AP2 pitching wedge - and the 8 & 9 irons feel like they have no "precision".  



Pardon my rambling... hopefully someone will find this helpful.

Curious why the iBlade was thrown out so easily?  You said you liked the feel and look of it, you had the second highest ball speed with (highest of the 7i) and the fastest swing speed with the Tour-V in it.  Sure it spun a bit more than the rest but it also launched 2* lower than most of the other clubs, so that has a negating effect on the spin.  

However, the MB w/ KBS Tour was really close behind it.  If you like the look and feel of it, it appears to be a really solid option for you, coming in only 1y behind the iBlade.

Also, spin is your friend when you are launching it that low.
G30 LS Tec - Ping Tour Stiff
Taylormade M2 Tour 15* - KK Silver DC 70X
Taylormade R15 TP 17* - Graphite Design MJ 6X
Titleist 816H2 22* - Project X HD2 6.0
Akira Prototype K-101 5-PW - Shimada K's Tour Stiff
Miura 50* - Aldila RIP 115 Stiff
Debating between: Mizuno T7, Cobra PUR One Length, Vokey SM7, Ping Glide Stealth
Bettinardi Inovai

13

#14 TNReb

TNReb

    Tour Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 611 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 206233
  • Joined: 10/08/2012
  • Location:Tennessee
  • Handicap:2
GolfWRX Likes : 117

Posted 14 October 2017 - 10:07 AM

View Postphatchrisrules, on 14 October 2017 - 09:16 AM, said:

Curious why the iBlade was thrown out so easily?  You said you liked the feel and look of it

I didnít say I liked the look of it. I said the look was different than Iím used to. It wasnít horrible, but it was my choice to stop trying it - not the fiitters. I have never hit a Ping iron I liked - I dont know if itís a mental thing or what.

14

#15 Hubijerk

Hubijerk

    Advanced

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 477 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 305901
  • Joined: 04/05/2014
  • Location:Las Vegas
  • Handicap:0
  • Ebay ID:hubijerk2p7b
GolfWRX Likes : 219

Posted 27 December 2017 - 12:16 PM

Just curious, you have Modus 130 shafts that work for you, but you demoed irons in pretty much everything but that...  The Dynamic gold s400 and x100 would be similar shafts.. All the shafts you tested aren't really even close in profile and a few of them have very different balance points...  The Modus 120TX would be a better fit for a 130x player as the 120x will be more active and spin more (I know, I went through that and game 120TX now).

Personally I think there is no better steel than the Nippon line, quality, performance, plus all the shafts I've bought from them are within .5g which is impressive (and DG makes you pay extra for).

I doubt you would get much improvement over you're ap2's in general but it doesn't seem like this was a particularly scientific or thorough test.  I would say pick whatever club you liked the most, not necessarily hit the best.. order a 7 iron, or find one used on the bay or wherever. get it with a 130x shaft at you're specs, or bend it to them, then go out and play and alternate shots with you're gamer and see.  It ends up not being that expensive plus if you like it and build a set you now have a ball beater for practice.  That's how I decided on my MP-18's, I had to build one myself because Mizuno doesn't offer the 120TX... But once I got it out there, bent it, lead taped it, put my grip on it.. way different than in the fitting.

You can pretty much make any iron play like any other iron... you can't change the look and impact feel that much though.

You can't sneak the cheese by a rat

15

#16 xjohnx

xjohnx

    Major Winner

  • Advanced Members
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,696 posts
  •  
  • Member #: 75904
  • Joined: 02/23/2009
  • Location:NH
  • Ebay ID:xedgep90x
GolfWRX Likes : 966

Posted 27 December 2017 - 01:31 PM

I wish fittings were what we all want them to be, but they're not and I know that. I'm not judging here but it seems like that's a lot of time and travel wasted to go to a fitting without the proper options. I'd be bummed if I I couldn't test new clubs with the shafts I like or the shafts I know work for me. I like the open mind approach and think that's wise but I'm guessing you left with a lot of unanswered questions bouncing around in your head. It also seems strange that you didn't hit the new AP2 but then again, one would argue that maybe that's not a true "upgrade" from your 716's. Your numbers with your set seem better than most of the irons you tested. I'm guessing the shaft has something to do with that.

I guess you could just choose the head you liked the look and feel and order them with your shafts? Tough call, I'm guessing you're at least a little frustrated making it hard to pull the trigger on anything at this point. At the end of the day, paying for a fitting and finding out your clubs are great is still more cost effective than buying new clubs with no fitting just to find out they don't work for you. In golf, peace of mind is invaluable.

16



0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

GolfWRX Sponsors