hoganfan924, on Mar 2 2008, 04:05 PM, said:
Dariusz,
couple of things. First an all important quote: "It is far better to do the right things adequately, than to do the wrong things beautifully."
When you create a drill where you encourage the arms to move back with very little pivot, you are engraining the feeling that the arms are working independently of the torso. That defines "out of synch" to me. With the description you gave, you'll also have your hands very deep - too far behind you for the type of swing that Slicefixer teaches. That kind of deep position will require the "right hand throwover move" that Hardy teaches. Seems like a big unnecessary complication to me.
Now it's very clear from your posts that you are a huge fan of Ben Hogan's golf swing and that you would like to emulate his swing. It's also very clear that you've done a lot of homework and studied whatever materials are available to you in Poland, like 5 Lessons, The plane truth, and the plane truth masters class as well as participating in forums. Given the difficulty of your circumstances, you've done quite a remarkable job to learn what you have. But, you need to decide who you want to believe concerning what Hogan really did. Do any of Hardy's students or 1PS devotees (Jacobsen, O. Brown, Pernice, etc.) look anything like Hogan to you? Or do Slicefixer's students look more "Hoganesque" to you? As a long time "student" of Hogan myself, I can assure you that Slicefixer doesn't "teach out of 5 Lessons" yet many of his long time and good students have a lot of the essential Hogan qualities in their swings. Slicefixer didn't even tell the student in the Hogan comparison that he swung like Hogan as that student doesn't like to watch a lot of video and Slicefixer didn't want his students ego to get inflated. So that student was in no way trying to emulate Hogan for the camera. He's been Slice's student since he was 13 years old.
I think the video comparing his student to Hogan should remove any doubt as to whether Slicefixer has a grasp as to what Hogan really did. I can promise you, he doesn't teach "starting lawnmowers," " throwing the right arm" or hitting with the right hand. Quite the opposite.
HoganFan,
Also a couple of things.
First, please stop associate me with Hardy's theory when I discuss Hogan's swing. I have already underlined that when I discuss Hogan, I discuss only Hogan, and, what I am saying or arguing is free of any OP theory - I guess you have omitted my certain posts e.g. where I discuss (even with another Hardy devotee) what is different between it and the real swing of Mr.Hogan.
Second, I cannot agree that all SF's students look identically to Mr.Hogan. Some of them have their bodies just less open at impact that it is necessary to emulate what Hogan did. Mind you, there is a staight correlation between the body angle at impact and the amount of having both arms in front of the body. Mr. Hogan had a open body at impact and his right arm was not in front of his body.
Thirdly, IMHO, the arms are in synch when they move parallelly in time in relation to the body turn. They are not in synch if the body stops before impact and the arms are going in front of the body in urge to hit the ball. My version of the drill, as I said, is for people who struggle with this flaw. I have struggled with a poor body turn and this drill helped me to get rid of it.
I want to underline again, that if a golfer is able to hit with an open body at impact he/she won't need my version - SF's version is perfect for him.
I saw a lot of great looking rotary swings (pro or amateur) that introduced (completely unnecessarily) the timing element into the impact zone only because their owners were not able to hit the ball without both arms in front of the body and, therefore, with arms "out of synch", as you said - they were not able to have their bodies open at impact.
Lastly, SliceFixer is the most knowledgeable guy as regards Hogan swing I've ever meet on all fora. I regard his Hogan knowledge as superior to all so-called Hogan experts. That is why I so willingly participate in this Forum and so willingly share my thoughts (whatever, if they are right or wrong) being anxious to discuss them. But even SliceFixer is not the next reincarnation of Mr.Hogan - therefore, I let myself not to accept what he is saying explicite 100% right, especially, if my feel or belief is slightly different. having said that, I stress again that my question to him about the drill was just a question and not an attempt to discredit his great drill.
I do hope I am clear enough - if you want to discuss further what "out of synch" really means - I'll be all ears for your meritoric arguments.