Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Phone call prompted Weir penalty review
GolfWRX.com > Tour and Pre-Release Info > Tournament Talk - Tourney News, Stories and Opinions
MtlJeff
http://blogs.golf.com/golf-truth-rumors/20...eir-review.html

it's a safe bet it was someone from this site biggrin.gif .... Who would call in against Weir in the Canadian open man!

on a serious note, maybe it's been discussed before. But does anyone think these armchair officials should just leave it to the actual officials?
jclark07
Maybe it was a Canadian, eh?
SpartyOn1982
HA! My goodness! What are the odds?
Tmiller72
I think it's horrible that people can phone in if they think they see something.
tbowles411
Ridiculous. The call was made, the tourney is over. This has GOT to stop!
3onpar5
Why does the PGA even take phone calls? They should just say, "yeah...uh huh...got it" and hang up. And who knows this number??!!!
clevelandgolf00
busted2.gif java script:add_smilie(%22:busted2:%22,%22smid_138%22)

haha just kidding leaves the rules to the rules people.
idiotbox
Who do you call and where do you get the number? Whomever does that should have the balls beaten off them.
OpusX20
I can't believe they even take those calls. How do you even know who to call? How does that conversation go? "Um...this is Bill in Peoria. Is Mr. Finchem there? I have an HDTV and a 1995 copy of the Rules of Golf. I know he would want to take my call. I think Tiger's ball crossed the hazzard 4 inches behind where he took his drop. Put me through to Mr. Finchem NOW!"
ctime
I hate people calling in. Sit on the couch, drink your beer, watch golf, and don't pick up your phone. There are these people called rules officials at the tournament. Let them do their job.

Why don't these same people call the NBA/David Stern every time an NBA players walks?!?!?
Gungagalunga
What's the number or how do you make contact?
pfgplm
Twas I
robb01
Was I asleep when they posted the number to report this? seriously, who takes the time to lookup the number after the actual officials have made a a ruling
Mward2002
They probably call the tournament host site and ask to speak to a rules official, blah blah.

These d-bags should just be hung up on, they have yet to prove any good or useful to any tournament. Rules officials were called in by Weir the minute it happened, it's not like he tried to avoid the situation like it never happened.

Shame on the PGA Tour for even making it a second review.
ava08
I am not a big Wie fan, matter of fact I couldn't stand her or her camp, but when that SI writer called or approached the offical (forgot scenario exactly) I vowed that if I ever met him I would beat him sensless. I HATE these people HATE HATE HATE them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Pweb44
QUOTE (OpusX20 @ Jul 28 2009, 11:37 PM) *
I can't believe they even take those calls. How do you even know who to call? How does that conversation go? "Um...this is Bill in Peoria. Is Mr. Finchem there? I have an HDTV and a 1995 copy of the Rules of Golf. I know he would want to take my call. I think Tiger's ball crossed the hazzard 4 inches behind where he took his drop. Put me through to Mr. Finchem NOW!"


Now that is funny......but at the same time probably a true conversation on the phone from the caller
HeadonaStick
Everyone inside the ropes is responsible to protect the field and the integrity of the game. Everyone outside the ropes is a spectator, and should remain a spectator.
boomgoesthedynamite
QUOTE (ava08 @ Jul 29 2009, 12:00 PM) *
I am not a big Wie fan, matter of fact I couldn't stand her or her camp, but when that SI writer called or approached the offical (forgot scenario exactly) I vowed that if I ever met him I would beat him sensless. I HATE these people HATE HATE HATE them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1


Michael Bamberger

I completely agree. As a journalist, it is his job to cover the tournament, not become part of the story.
lagwagon23
QUOTE (ava08 @ Jul 29 2009, 10:00 AM) *
I am not a big Wie fan, matter of fact I couldn't stand her or her camp, but when that SI writer called or approached the offical (forgot scenario exactly) I vowed that if I ever met him I would beat him sensless. I HATE these people HATE HATE HATE them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1


No you won't.
callawayfan
how do you know that?
Foreleft
Obviously I missed part of the story, but I thought Weir was immediately concerned when he saw the ball move that he had soled his club. He called the rules official over, who discussed it with him and they agreed that he would play on and review the film later. After video review, I thought no penalty was assessed (even though I truly thought he had soled his club).

With that background, what was a viewer at home able to see that the rules official did not?
MCCA
No other sport could you pull this non-sense
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.