Connect with us

Opinion & Analysis

This is why the U.S. team can’t win a Ryder Cup on the road

Published

on

The inquest has begun after the U.S. team was trounced by the Europeans at Le Golf National to lose their grip on the Ryder Cup. Many are pointing the finger at the lack of desire shown by the group of players involved, while others have questioned Captain Furyk’s strategic decisions throughout the week at Le Golf National. Some are also laying the blame at the team dynamic, which does indeed look far more distant than the tight-knit group of players that Team Europe possesses.

But just how does a more talented group of players get thumped so convincingly by a less accomplished team? Well, the insular culture of the United States is as important a factor as any.

As far as myths go, the rumors that have circulated across Europe throughout the years over what percentage of United States citizens hold passports is a pretty good one. The number that broadcast was always so far under the actual reality, and it is now common knowledge that more Americans hold passports today than at any other time in their history. Still, the myth was evidence of how the rest of the world saw the United States as living inside its little bubble. While the insistence on declaring the winners of the Super Bowl and World Series as World Champions, despite both competitions only possessing sides from the United States, is another detail that supports the rest of the world’s view that the United States is an inward-looking country.

How does this insular culture pertain to this year’s failure at the Ryder Cup?

Well, earlier this year, The French Open was held at Le Golf National. A perfect opportunity for Team USA’s 12 members to play the course in tournament conditions, an experience that would undoubtedly have helped them when they arrived to do battle against Europe in September. How many of the 12 players turned up? One. Just one solitary member decided it was worth the effort to get on a plane, travel across the Atlantic ocean and spend a week in Paris getting accustomed to Le Golf National in championship conditions. That man was Justin Thomas, and funnily enough, he was the USA’s best performer over the three days of action in Paris, collecting four points for his country.

I can hear the counter-argument being something similar to: “You can’t expect elite PGA Tour professionals to sacrifice the significantly greater earning power on the PGA Tour to play more events in Europe.” I’m not expecting that at all. But there can be no arguing that the French Open at the end of June was the perfect opportunity for the United States to lessen the distinct advantage that the Europeans would have at Le Golf National, and they didn’t take it. The PGA Tour event on that same week was the Quicken Loans National. How many of the U.S. side played in that event? Just the two, Rickie Fowler and Tiger Woods, meaning nine of the U.S. 2018 Ryder Cup side took the week off instead of being pro-active like their teammate Justin Thomas, who deserves a lot of credit for both his preparation and performance at Le Golf National.

Do the United States players care enough? 

I believe they do. We saw incredible passion from the side at Hazeltine two years ago on their way to a spectacular victory. We didn’t see a fraction of that emotion at Le Golf National because they were exposed on the course, and as a result, it drained their confidence. They did not have a clue how to play the golf course. They were away from their happy place of playing target golf on courses in the United States where rough is barely even a factor. The difference in performance by U.S. players on tracks on the PGA Tour compared to their showing on courses like Le Golf National has become comparable to U.S. tennis players ability to perform on hard courts in their own country and their struggles on the European clay courts throughout history.

Jim Furyk is not at fault for this lack of ability of his players to perform on golf courses that require thought, strategy and execution. However, we have Patrick Reed, one of the nine team members sitting at home when the French Open was being played, criticising his captain for not playing himself more, citing his past Ryder Cup record as the reason he should have seen more action. Well, Patrick, you were fortunate to see three sessions. On Saturday morning you produced one of the worst Ryder Cup performances in history, knocking the ball twice in the water and once out of bounds from tee shots in the first few holes. You seemed to have improved a little by Sunday afternoon, an improvement that may have been fast-tracked had you taken the effort to board a plane in late June and get yourself accustomed to Le Golf National in preparation for the Ryder Cup.

What’s next for Team USA?

The U.S. will reclaim the Ryder Cup in 2020. They are a more talented group on golf courses where they are comfortable. They will then go to Rome in 2022, where it will have been 31 years since they last defeated Europe away from home. U.S. fans should be hoping by the time that event rolls around, more players decide to show the attitude and mindset of Justin Thomas, as until the U.S. team loses its fear of getting out of their comfort zone, they will continue to fail on the road at the Ryder Cup.

Your Reaction?
  • 195
  • LEGIT23
  • WOW4
  • LOL1
  • IDHT2
  • FLOP2
  • OB0
  • SHANK19

Gianni is a freelance writer. He holds a Bachelor of Arts as well as a Diploma in Sports Journalism. He can be contacted at gmagliocco@outlook.com. Follow him on Twitter @giancarlomag

14 Comments

14 Comments

  1. Glftips

    Oct 2, 2018 at 11:32 am

    I agree with the take on Americans lack of preparation and the pettiness of Reed. The Americans did not adjust to the narrow fairways and slow greens while the Euro’s were in their element. As for being insular in regard to major sports..could and country field a team that could win or compete for a Super Bowl, World Series or NBA Championship?

  2. William Davis

    Oct 2, 2018 at 10:45 am

    Perhaps there was a degree of arrogance with the US players. Believe they are best in the world and only need to turn up to win. When it was all over they looked bemused and forlorn. Hopefully, a lesson learnt, albeit, the hard way.

    • Scott

      Oct 2, 2018 at 5:35 pm

      They get taught this lesson just about every 4 years

  3. RyderStop

    Oct 2, 2018 at 7:07 am

    hit the fairway, hit the green….make allot of pars. Thats the formula, it was a US open type setup. U.S. refused to play it as such

  4. Ulf

    Oct 2, 2018 at 1:30 am

    Seeing the percieved superiority of the American players comes from playing mostly on courses that demand little more than driving the ball as far as possible, then hit a wedge into the green while they failed miserably on course that could, based on your description, be seen as a more complete test of golf – are you absolutely sure the Americans are the more talented team?

  5. buddy6713

    Oct 1, 2018 at 8:20 pm

    Well reasoned opinion and I agree with all the conclusions you reach. Want to add one more factor to the mix, the difference between the generally self effacing, jovial, mostly relaxed camaraderie that exists not just in the European Ryder Cup team but the fabric of the dominant UK region and the Euro Tour. There’s just a huge difference in the lifestyle of the two cultures. To say that kind of difference is meaningless when it comes to executing shots and playing at the level one is accustomed is to say that only Xs and Os count on the basketball court not the crowd the familiarity with the arena, etc.

    It’s kind of all connected, isn’t it?

  6. rex235

    Oct 1, 2018 at 6:35 pm

    It’s the curse of Seve!

    Better yet, maybe the Curse of Larry Nelson.

    Who was Larry Nelson? The guy who started learning the game at 21, and by 31 was a PGA Winner.

    Three Majors, (US Open and 2 PGAs), 5-0-0 in Ryder Cup play, even beating Seve Ballesteros, but-

    Was overlooked by the PGA of America for US Ryder Cup Captain in ’97 in Spain against Seve.

    At the time, the PGA quote against Nelson was- “HE WASN’T FAMILIAR ENOUGH WITH THE PLAYERS.”

    Been 25 years since the US Ryder Cup team won in Europe. The next European Ryder Cup location?

    Italy. Home of Open Champion Francesco Molinari, who went 5-0-0 this year.

    Good Luck at Whistling Straits in 2020.

  7. BennyHogan

    Oct 1, 2018 at 3:38 pm

    Ryder Cup has a long and storied tradition so it is might be overcommercialized, but the history makes it what it is and tradition is everthing to golf IMO.

  8. Progolfer

    Oct 1, 2018 at 3:30 pm

    The U.S. lost because they couldn’t play the golf course. They were too errant for Le Golf National. That’s it. It has nothing to do with team chemistry etc. At the end of the day, it comes down to the individual doing his job, and the Americans didn’t.

  9. Tom

    Oct 1, 2018 at 3:08 pm

    Yawn, the Ryder Cup is an over-hyped exhibition that makes TV networks and the PGA a pile of money…..nothing more

    • Jesse

      Oct 1, 2018 at 4:42 pm

      As opposed to every other tournament? That’s what televised sports is… Stop trolling…

    • Colin gillbanks

      Oct 1, 2018 at 4:46 pm

      Especially when your team loses…..

      • Tom

        Oct 1, 2018 at 6:55 pm

        Difference is, this exhibition is the only event players do NOT get compensated….BIG difference, now that I explained it to you, can you understand, Jesse Boy and Colin Blo?

        • Simon

          Oct 2, 2018 at 9:45 am

          Seriously?? “Compensated”? Then again, maybe that’s it. The US team only get out of bed for money? Pretty sad state of affairs eh, little Tommy?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Opinion & Analysis

Brooks Koepka’s coach, Claude Harmon III, on BK’s PGA Championship victory, working with the game’s best, and more

Published

on

Coming fresh of the celebration of Brooks Koepka’s fourth major win, Koepka’s long-time coach, Claude Harmon III chatted with Johnny Wunder as he was just about to hop on a plane back to The Floridian.

Here are the highlights of their conversation.

JW: Claude how you doin’?

CH3: Uh, I’m hungover!

JW: Brooks is walking off the 18th green after another major triumph. What is the first thing you guys said to each other?

CH3: Well, obviously there was a lot of emotion in that moment, but he told me it was the happiest he has ever been on the golf course, and after everything he’s done, that’s a big statement.

For him to put in all the hard work and to fight as hard as he did on a golf course that completely changed on the last day and come out on top makes me extremely grateful to be a part of the team that supports that. I believe he will find out more about himself from getting through the final nine holes than he would if he would have had a parade coming in and won by seven.

JW: That’s a great point. It seems like he is more apt to win even more majors based on that back nine than he would have otherwise.

CH3: I don’t think if you were watching it on TV you could have any appreciation for just how difficult it was. What DJ did yesterday was impossible and having that up ahead applies even more pressure to a leader. Ricky Elliott and BK are looking at the scoreboard and seeing DJ and 3 under and having no idea how that’s even possible. It was that tough.

JW: I think Brooks stubbornness is part of his true greatness. Would you agree?

CH3: His perspective constantly was “I’m still in the lead and someone is going to have to catch me and this golf course is extremely difficult.” Even after all the bogeys on the back side, he still controlled the lead and kept that mantra. The crowd yelling “DJ! DJ!” actually didn’t piss him off, it woke him up.

JW: How did yesterday compare to Shinnecock? 

CH3: At Shinnecock it was an interesting situation because Fleetwood…posted before BK was even off and in that case, Brooks said it was like playing against a ghost. No matter what he does, Tommy isn’t going to make any more mistakes or change in any way. That’s a tough scenario when you are staring at a number that won’t move for 5 1/2 hours.

JW: What do Brooks and DJ have that people can learn from.

CH3: It’s funny because we hear these cliches in sports psychology all the time, but I believe those two are the living embodiment of ONE SHOT AT A TIME. They don’t look back. Ever.

JW: Speaking on DJ. I’m watching the back nine and thinking to myself this guy is playing out of his mind, it was literally a battle of the best.

CH3: We talk about it all the time in golf, what we always want is the two best players in the world going toe to toe. We had that yesterday and I hope as time goes by we can look at this final round as a battle we will be talking about for a long time. Best players in the world on a tough but fair golf course with the ultimate prize on the line. In situations like this when there is this kind of pressure and these stakes you can look at the leaderboard and see the cream rising to the top. Rory, DJ, Jordan all with good rounds on a really tough day.

JW: You met Brooks in 2013, he showed up in his mom’s beat up Explorer and don’t know him at all. What was your first impression?

CH3: I was introduced to him by Pete Uihlein, his old roommate, and at first glance, he had raw talent and a ton of speed, but no plan. At the time he was hitting a draw and was uncomfortable with that. He told me his current coach wanted him to hit draws, and I said well that’s your fault, not your coach’s. It’s the player’s responsibility to manage himself and the information he’s comfortable with. When we worked on him getting into a fade, he started to click and he turned to me and said “it can’t be this easy.” My reply was “it has to be this easy!” At that level, under the gun, it better be easy. [Golf is] tough enough already.

JW: What were his career goals early on?

CH3: Even then, he wanted to be an elite player who won multiple majors. I was coaching Ernie Els at the time who had just won his fourth major and Brooks was on the Challenge Tour. He was committed to getting there but needed guidance, someone with a plan that wasn’t just his golf swing. Obviously, it worked out.

JW: What would you say is the Harmon secret to getting the best players in the world to peak as often as you guys do?

CH3: My dad told me: “What you don’t say is just as important as what you do say.” At the Masters this year Brooks, in practice, was really struggling. Look, it’s Masters week and I’m not going to go in there and start putting thoughts in his head. At that point, if this is a shuttle launch, we are in the cockpit and there is no turning back. My dad always had his guys have a go-to shot that they “knew” they could hit. Brooks calls it his “fairway finder” which is a squeeze off fade with a driver. I told him to hit a couple of those knowing it might spur some confidence. After a few absolute flushed misses, his confidence went up and he turned to me and said…”fairway finder all day.” The rest is history.

JW: You coach DJ, Brooks, Jimmy Walker and Rickie. Describe each in one word

JW: DJ
CH3: Natural

JW: Brooks
CH3: Tough MF

JW: Rickie
CH3: Genuine

JW: Jimmy
CH3: Soulful

JW: Thanks old friend
CH3: Talk soon, thanks man.

Your Reaction?
  • 1
  • LEGIT0
  • WOW0
  • LOL0
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP0
  • OB0
  • SHANK0

Continue Reading

Podcasts

On Spec: Swing weight is overrated

Published

on

A deep dive into one of the most talked about but truly misunderstood aspects of club building: swing weight. What it really means, and why it isn’t the end all be all for a set of clubs.

Check out the full podcast on SoundCloud below, or click here to listen on iTunes or here to listen on Spotify.

Your Reaction?
  • 1
  • LEGIT0
  • WOW0
  • LOL1
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP1
  • OB1
  • SHANK13

Continue Reading

Courses

Ari’s Course Reviews: Bethpage Black

Published

on

Bethpage’s Black course was designed by A.W. Tillinghast and opened for play in 1936. It was immediately considered one of the best tests of golf in the world, and it has tested golfers coming from all over the world in its 83-year history. Bethpage State Park itself has five courses. The Green was the first course built and was originally called Lennox Hills Country Club. In the early 1930s, the Bethpage Park Authority purchased Lennox Hills CC and other adjacent property and turned the whole thing into what is now known as Bethpage State Park. Course architect A.W. Tillinghast was hired to remodel what would become the Green course as well as build the Blue, Red, and finally the Black. The Yellow Course was designed by Alfred Tull and opened in 1958.

Bethpage first hosted a major championship in 2002 when it hosted the U.S, Open. What is somewhat forgotten 17 years later as it hosts its third major, is how much the course had fallen into disrepair by the mid-1990s. Luckily, the USGA could see through all of that and helped fund a complete restoration that was overseen personally by Dave Catalano, the larger than life (in both stature and personality) head of Bethpage State Park. Dave had been working at Bethpage since he was a kid in 1967, picking up papers in the picnic area. It was his baby, and with Rees Jones by his side, they painstakingly restored the Black to its former greatness and into a true championship test of golf. After the PGA Championship, the Black will be back in the spotlight 2024 as host of the Ryder Cup, joining a very short list of courses to host a U.S. Open, a PGA Championship, and a Ryder Cup.

Playing the Black is one of the most unique experiences in the game because of what it takes to get a tee time. There are a very limited number of tee times. They are easier to get if you are a NY resident, but for most of us, it’s first come, first serve. Which in practical terms means they have a parking lot with numbered spaces and people start showing up the day before to sleep in their cars to play. In fact, I can proudly say that the last three times I slept in my car it was just to play at Bethpage. One of those times I didn’t even get out on the Black and had to settle for playing the Red! Should have eaten dinner in the car I guess….

Every time I have slept in the car I have had a great time. It’s a party in the lot with a bunch of golfers hanging out all excited to play the next day. There’s usually a few beers around and one of the times, someone called a cab and went and got 50 cheeseburgers from McDonald’s at 1 a.m. to show us all some top-notch NY hospitality! That’s definitely not an experience you will have going to play any other top courses!

Once you finally do get to sleep, the staff wakes you up around 4 a.m. to go get in line and get your tee time and course assignment. Then you can go back to sleep or go eat breakfast or hit balls or whatever you want until it’s your turn to tee off. On your way to the tee, you see the famous WARNING sign telling you that the Black Course is an extremely difficult course which they recommend only for highly skilled golfers. Hopefully, you didn’t lose your tee ticket because you will need that to get onto the tee and trust me, they aren’t messing around with the rules!

The golf course itself sits on a huge, sprawling, fantastic piece of land with abundant elevation change and lots of random contours. The bunkering is big and bold and not to be messed with. There is abundant long fescue and numerous trees off to the sides of the holes which combined with the beautiful bunkering makes for a very beautiful setting.

The first hole is a downhill, almost 90-degree dogleg right. The fairway is pretty flat and so is the well-bunkered green. The key for the player is to put their drive into the right place in the fairway to get a good angle to the hole location. From here you cross Round Swamp Rd and head to the second, which is a short, uphill par 4 of 389 yards. The fairway slants a little right to left and the green is elevated and can be a challenge to hold. The third is a par 3 that plays about 160 yards normally but has been brought back to 230 the PGA. This is one of the more interesting greens on the course; it’s wide on the right and falls away as it gets to the back and tapers to a smaller, more narrow section on the left. Bunkers flank the short left and right side of the green.

The fourth hole is vintage Bethpage Black and probably the most photographed on the course. A huge bunker flanks the left side of the fairway off the tee of the 517-yard par-5. Another, even more huge bunker looms at the end of the fairway cut into the from right to left. The tee shot is downhill but the rest of the hole is uphill. There is a second fairway to layup over the big bunker where you will have a partial view of the small, flattish green that falls away slightly and is protected by two more deep bunkers to the front and left. The fifth is a monster par 4 of almost 480 yards. A massive fairway bunker guards the right side of the fairway which is also the best angle to come into the small, elevated green guarded by two deep bunkers short and one over the green.

FARMINGDALE, NEW YORK – MAY 15: A general view of the fifth green is seen during a practice round prior to the 2019 PGA Championship at the Bethpage Black course on May 15, 2019 in Farmingdale, New York. (Photo by Stuart Franklin/Getty Images)

No. 6 gets back into the more open and less tree-lined part of the property. The tee shot is semi-blind and over a hill. The landing area is pinched by bunkers on both sides. The long hitter who can carry the hill should have a very short shot into the flattish, oval shaped green that’s open in front and protected by bunkers on both sides. No. 7 is a converted par 5 that plays as a par 4 for the PGA. At 524 yards, it’s very long and the tee shot requires a long poke over another large fairway bunker. The green is again pretty flat and protected by deep bunkers in front.

The eighth hole is unique for the Black as it’s the only hole with water in play. A 210-yard drop shot to a green with some slope from right to left and front to back and a ridge running on a diagonal angle through the middle of the green. The shot must carry the pond short of the green and there is a deep bunker left and a hillside right. Nine is a 460-yard hard dogleg left that drops down off the tee and back up to the green. Another very deep bunker guards the left side and can be carried by the longer hitter. The right side of the fairway is the safe play off the tee but leaves an awkward shot out of a gully up to the green. The green is heavily guarded in front again by deep bunkers.

As the players make the turn, they are confronted with another long, tight par 4 of just over 500 yards. Hitting the fairway is key here as the fairway is heavily guarded by bunkers and fescue. The green sits on the other side of a little gully and is guarded once again by a set of deep bunkers. The 11th hole is 435 yards and has probably the most interesting green on the course. It has a little false front and two distinct tiers with some nice internal movement. A really good green on any course it stands out on the Black amongst what is mostly a flatter set of greens. 12 forces the players to carry it 285 over a massive cross bunker on the 515-yard par 4. The green is back to the more typical flattish oval, and characteristically is guarded in the front on both sides by deep bunkers. 13 is a par 5 of over 600 yards. One of the least bunkered holes on the course, there are a few bunkers on the left and a great little cross bunker about 60 yards short of the green that obscures the view of the green and will make the players think twice about going for the green in two. 14 is the best chance for birdie on the course. A par 3 that plays only 160 yards over a valley to a narrow, long green.

After walking off the 14th green the players cross back over Round Swamp Road to the home stretch of the course. 15 is always the hardest hole on the course for me when I play the Black. The hole plays 460 yards. The tee shot is flat to a fairway that bends slightly right to left and has no bunkers. The second shot is massively uphill. Over a hillside set with bunkers and a small section of fairway to a green set into the top of the hill and guarded by the deepest bunkers on the course. A very hard hole to make par if you miss the fairway or miss the green. The 16th has a downhill tee shot that will test the player’s judgement of the wind if there is any present. The green is well guarded especially to the right and is small with a little slant to it. The 17th is an uphill brute of a 210-yard par 3. The green is 45 yards wide and is huge. However, it does not look big from the tee as it is set amongst a veritable minefield of bunkers waiting to swallow up any wayward shots. The players walk up a hill to the 18th tee and stare down at a fairway that gets severely pinched in the middle by the huge bunkers on both sides. The green is then back uphill, it’s medium sized with a slight kidney shape and two deep, artistically shaped bunkers set into the hillside short.

All of this adds up to a great test of championship golf.  The course is pretty straightforward. There is not a ton of strategy other than hit it long and straight and make as many putts as you can. The greens are mostly pretty flat so there should be a lot of chances for birdie for those that can reach the greens in regulation. That said, the course has a ton of character when it comes to the land movement and elevation changes as well as the massive, artistic bunkers. New Yorkers are VERY proud of the Black and for a very good reason. It’s a fantastic golf course. Golf needs more top courses like the Black that are accessible to everyone and challenging to even the best players in the world.

 

Your Reaction?
  • 12
  • LEGIT0
  • WOW0
  • LOL0
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP0
  • OB0
  • SHANK2

Continue Reading

19th Hole

Facebook

Trending