Connect with us

Opinion & Analysis

Can Tiger Woods be the New Ben Hogan?



Now that the wait is over and Tiger Woods’ comeback to the PGA Tour is underway, I think the time has come to compare this comeback to the greatest comeback of all time: the 1950 return of Ben Hogan. In 1949, Ben Hogan was severally injured and permanently disabled when his car was hit head on by a speeding Greyhound bus. During his rehab, Hogan learned that he could still swing a golf club. He also learned that he wanted — more than anything — to return to tournament golf. And from what I understand, Tiger is the same way. He wants to win more major championships.

“I’m at 14, and the record’s 18, and of course I want to get there/ I set out to try and get to 19 … when I was 12, 13 years old. I thought that was the mark of all marks.” — Tiger Woods

So how did it go for Hogan? Well, a severely diminished Ben Hogan came back from that horrific accident to win the 1950 U.S. Open. Then he went on to win five more majors over the next four seasons. My best guess would be if Tiger needs a target, goal, objective or inspiration to exceed what Jack Nicklaus accomplished, then what Ben Hogan did would be it. I am going to take the position that Tiger doesn’t have to reinvent the comeback wheel. I believe that if Tiger does what Ben Hogan did, Tiger will get what Hogan got. Think about it. Five more majors. OK, so what did Hogan do?

“I was a much better golfer before the accident than I ever was afterward.” — Ben Hogan

First, Hogan learned that he didn’t need a new golf swing. He just started out doing what he could and just kept building on that. As I understand it, Tiger has done the same thing. Hogan’s goal was to get as good as he reasonably and safely could — not to be as good as he once was. Hopefully, Tiger can incorporate that mindset into his preparations. By parting ways with his most recent swing instructor, Tiger is telling us that he knows his golf swing better than any teacher — and that he’s finally ready to trust it. Butch Harmon, the top-rated teacher in the world, agrees that “[Tiger] knows more about the golf swing than I do.” Using modern technology, none of which was available to Hogan, Tiger will dig whatever he needs “out of the dirt.”

“The ultimate judge of your swing is the flight of the ball.” — Ben Hogan

Second, Hogan modified his practice to accommodate his broken body. He became much more focused on deliberate practice than in the past. He loved to hit balls, but now he had to be mindful of the toll for excess. He had to make each ball count for something, and he always wrote down what he was doing and how it was coming along. Tiger should take heed and, if necessary, retain a “practice manager” to maximize his practice time.

“I am trying to play myself back in shape. I just haven’t had enough competition. I’m hitting the ball as well as I ever did, but I’ve lost the knack of scoring.” — Ben Hogan

Third, Tiger has to get his game up to speed, and though I think swing instruction for him is unnecessary and potential damaging, I do think Tiger could benefit from individual expertise on an as needed basis. What really separates the players of today from those of the past is short game and wedge technique, not ball striking. More players today are capable of shooting low scores than Hogan faced.

Additionally, modern performance training and “best practices” coaching has demonstrated and proven that simulated environments that control the circumstances of the practice activity can substantially improve performance in actual competition. You must be aware that Hogan played a very limited schedule after the accident. In fact, he only played in six official events in 1953 (he won five). So where did the “competition” come from? I submit that it came from his preparation.

“Placing the ball in the right position for the next shot is 80 percent of winning golf.”  — Ben Hogan

Finally, Hogan knew he wasn’t as good as before, and he knew everyone else knew that as well. But what he knew, which no one suspected, was that he didn’t have to be as good as he once was. He just had to be good enough. The same applies to Tiger, whether he knows it or not.

“The majors were the easiest to win because nine out of 10 players choke when the prize is in sight.” — Jack Nicklaus

Your Reaction?
  • 142
  • LEGIT10
  • WOW4
  • LOL3
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP1
  • OB1
  • SHANK36

Ed Myers is the author of Hogan’s Ghost, Golf’s Scoring Secret and The Scoring Machine. He was the Director of Instruction at Memphis National Golf Club, and he is currently the scoring coach for players on all professional tours. "The Ultimate Scoring and Performance Experience" an all day program featuring on course private instruction and unlimited play with "Hogan's Ghost." is now available. More than a "golf school"and more than just short game. Individualized evaluation determines where to start the experience. Learn and work according to your goals, preferences and ability. All practice is supervised and structured to ensure maximum benefit and verifiable results. Program runs Monday -Friday from April through October, 2018. See you in Memphis, Tenn. "The Distance Coaching Program" is now available to all level of golfers worldwide. Thanks to modern technology everyone, everywhere, can train like a touring professional. Learn more about Ed at He can be reached at



  1. Ben Jones

    Feb 28, 2018 at 5:53 pm

    Hit his driver like Hogan? Control his irons like Hogan? Use balata balls, blades and woods like Hogan? Nope.

  2. Dennis Silvers

    Feb 16, 2018 at 9:46 pm

    Hogan almost won his 1st tournament after coming back from his accident. Tiger just missed the cut at Riviera and will continue to flounder.

  3. CB

    Feb 14, 2018 at 1:12 am

    In a word, no. Mr Hogan wasn’t a nasty voyeuristic skirt-chasing adulterous dirt bag like Eldrick.

  4. Ben Jones

    Feb 13, 2018 at 1:22 pm

    No one will ever be Ben Hogan just like no one will ever be Jack Nicklaus. Those days are gone.

  5. integrity matters

    Feb 12, 2018 at 9:12 pm

    No. Ben Hogan had integrity. Mr. Woods is sorely lacking in that. Ben Hogan never cheated in the Masters. Mr Woods has.

  6. Steve S

    Feb 12, 2018 at 5:39 pm

    It’s amazing what has happened to reading comprehension in this country. He’s not comparing the injuries. He’s saying use Hogan as a model for a comeback. Why wouldn’t you use Hogan as an example?

  7. Jordan

    Feb 12, 2018 at 3:03 pm

    I know all the hard core hogan fans hate when tiger and Ben are mentioned in the same breath but I think this areticle is a great blueprint for tiger to follow. Not really comparable injury situation though. 1953 is the greatest display of tournament golf ever period.

  8. Jack Nash

    Feb 12, 2018 at 2:35 pm

    Hogan’s crash? He almost died. He was lucky to make it.That being said it’s kind of obvious his abilities would be seriously degraded.(permantly disabled, broken body) Woods never went thru that. His injuries were caused by golf, not a major auto accident. I really don’t see a comparison with reading the article. I see a wanted comparison. That being said I see similarities with the mind. Both strong willed people. That can make up for a lot of other discrepancies. Woods I think will just want to compete, and be healthy to start. He’s obviously aiming for the Masters, but will have to work on his 2 way miss. What I do like about Woods come back is he’s more willing to reveal himself more, which is refreshing. Still a nice read though.

  9. Sven Olsen

    Feb 12, 2018 at 1:49 pm

    The idea may be fascinating, but!!

    Ben Hogan was a one-off golfer in so many ways – Tiger, with his obvious stubborness and other positive sides, do not, I am sorry to say, reach Hogan to the knees.

  10. Mark

    Feb 12, 2018 at 12:57 pm

    Very nice read! History repeats itself and this is an interesting analogy amoung two of the greatest

  11. William Davis

    Feb 12, 2018 at 12:39 pm

    It is MR Hogan to you lot. Silly article jumping on the hysterical media band wagon. Still, good luck to Woods but I prefer TV coverage when he is absent.

    • Gerald Teigrob

      Feb 12, 2018 at 1:08 pm

      Not me, but you might do well to move the needle yourself. Tiger still moves the needle and for those of us walking wounded he is clearly more of an inspiration than you will ever be!

  12. farmer

    Feb 12, 2018 at 12:12 pm

    Hogan’s body was broken, but not his mind. Tiger’s mind spiraled out of control, then his body broke.

    • Gerald Teigrob

      Feb 12, 2018 at 1:11 pm

      And did you read the entire article? I have been where the mind spirals and I would say that you should be careful not to make light of it. Mental illness is curable but ignorance and blindness shows lack of sensitivity from others, which is really sad!

  13. Rev G

    Feb 12, 2018 at 12:03 pm

    My first impression of the article after reading the first paragraph was pretty much the same as the above post. But in reality the article isn’t really comparing the two situations or injuries – it’s saying that Woods should follow the game plan that Hogan used for his comeback if he wants to succeed. And I have to say I agree and I think all of us as we get older and more “banged up” can learn from how Hogan approached the game after his accident.

    • Ed Myers

      Feb 12, 2018 at 12:37 pm

      Thank you for your comment and for actually reading the article.

    • Gerald Teigrob

      Feb 12, 2018 at 1:18 pm

      Well said Rev G! Many of us have been through similar aspects of Tiger’s healing process. Many of us have developed bad knees from strain over the years and injuries. This article is more about what Tiger can do to follow in Ben’s footsteps. Wise words for all of us. Hogan set a model for those of us banged up amateurs would also do well to follow. And before we look at indicting Tiger we would do well to look at our own backyards to take the log out of our own eyes.

  14. Joro

    Feb 12, 2018 at 12:02 pm

    What planet does this “writer” live on to say this. Tiger was the best, but it is over and he does not have the same drive that Hogan had, no way. He has got everything in the World including many injuries and other problems, he well not win again!

  15. Jerry L Hoffman

    Feb 12, 2018 at 11:48 am

    Sorry but not even close comparison. Hogan was told he would never walk again multiple broken bones and legs crushed. Last day competition was always 36 holes not 18 making it even more remarkable. The other point rarely mentioned was Hogan’s eyesight was also effected making his depth perception compromised and major cause if his putting words.

  16. Kelly Gallagher

    Feb 12, 2018 at 11:48 am

    To compare Tigers comeback to Ben Hogan is just plain stupid. Hogan nearly died in that accident. Are you on crack or something. What a ridiculous thing to write about.

  17. Dale Winstead

    Feb 12, 2018 at 11:37 am

    Terrible comparison. Circumstances totally different. And let’s see if Tiger even wins let alone wins a major before writing clickbait articles like this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


The 19th Hole (Ep 77): Rick Reilly and Colin Montgomerie



Acclaimed sports writer Rick Reilly and Hall of Fame golfer Colin Montgomerie join host Michael Williams. Also features Adam Martin of Haig Point, South Carolina, where Michael recently made his first hole in one!

Check out the full podcast on SoundCloud below, or click here to listen on iTunes or here to listen on Spotify.

Your Reaction?
  • 0
  • LEGIT0
  • WOW0
  • LOL0
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP0
  • OB0
  • SHANK0

Continue Reading


Say it, Jim Nantz: “A golf destination like no other”



Millions-year-old limestone formations were integrated into the design at Mountain Top Golf Course near Branson, Missouri. The new course was designed by Gary Player in tandem with Bass Pros Shops Founder Johnny Morris.

Maybe it was while hitting to greens surrounded by stunning millions-year-old exposed limestone at Mountain Top Course.

Or it could have been when sipping a tequila concoction while riding my golf cart past underground waterfalls on the Lost Canyon Cave and Nature Trail, an unexpected mind-blower included with my greens fee at the adjacent Jack Nicklaus-designed Top of the Rock Golf Course.

No, I’m certain it came as I stood by the rustic-yet-luxury cabin at Big Cedar Lodge where I was attending the PGA TOUR Champions Bass Pro Legends of Golf. Waiting for a shuttle bus to the resort, I looked up from my mobile phone as a vehicle approached slowly on the narrow roads that wind throughout the property. Expecting it to be my ride, instead I see World Golf Hall of Famer Gary Player peering at me from the passenger seat of an SUV. He tips his hat to me and smiles, a first-class gesture from perhaps the game’s most renowned gentleman.

cavern, cave, golf course, geology, waterfalls

A view from inside the Lost Canyon Cave and Nature Trail, admission to which comes with your greens fee at Top of the Rock Golf Course.

It’s not easy to pinpoint precisely when I knew I was in a truly unique golf place. But it didn’t take long as one first-of-its-kind experience followed another. Moreover, there are approximately 17,500 courses in North America, but only one place where they’re coming online so fast and so distinctly. The burgeoning golf development in the Branson area features a who’s who of golf legends and course designers, including Tiger Woods, Nicklaus, Player, Tom Fazio and Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw.

The geological theme runs through the area golf product, thanks in part to Bass Pro Shops Founder Johnny Morris, who is building many courses as amenities of his Big Cedar Lodge. Mountain Top joins Top of the Rock and Buffalo Ridge Springs Golf Course with geology and conservation inspiration illuminating the Missouri Ozarks’ natural gifts. Buffalo graze adjacent to the latter course, and Top of the Rock sits perched high above the expansive, pristine Table Rock Lake. The course clubhouse includes 150-year-old wood beams transported from a barn in Arnold Palmer’s hometown in Latrobe, Pa. (Palmer designed the mind-boggling all-synthetic-turf driving range, and he and Morris became good friends.)

lake branson big cedar lodge

Top of the Rock Golf Course overlooks Table Rock Lake, and its clubhouse (“Arnie’s Barn”) includes 150-year-old wood beams from a barn in Latrobe, Pa.

Two new courses will open in 2019 and 2020 – Ozarks National and Payne’s Valley – both highly anticipated because the former will be played along with Top of the Rock in the Legends of Golf tourney taking place this week (Friday-Sunday), and the latter is authored by Tiger Woods and his golf architecture firm, TGR Design. It is Woods’ first ever public course – and includes a spectacular 19th hole with remarkable stone outcroppings and waterfalls – bringing to five the number of new courses that will have recently opened in the destination. That’s supersonic speed compared to the turtle’s pace that is post-recession golf course development worldwide.

Designed by Coore and Crenshaw, Ozarks National opens to the public on April 29, a day after of the Legends of Golf concludes. You can be among the first folks ever to see the course by watching Golf Channel’s coverage of the Legends of Golf on Friday through Sunday. If you tune in, you’ll see a course lovingly integrated into Morris’ beloved Ozarks (he hails from nearby Springfield). He’s spent most of his live extolling the area’s natural virtues, and he’s gone to great lengths to preserve and illuminate them.

Golf Course, Big Cedar Golf, Branson, Missouri

Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw’s Ozarks National Golf Course will open to the public on Monday, April 29, one day after the Bass Pro Legends of Golf PGA TOUR Champions event concludes.

If you’re looking for a different kind of place for your next golf trip, you might consider this Ozarks oasis in Southwest Missouri. The grandeur of the setting and the world-class golf courses will astound. But don’t take my word for it. Watch this video clip and image Jim Nantz cooing about the grace and beauty of this inimitable golf place.

Big Cedar Lodge’s Mountain Top golf course April 2018 from Bass Pro Shops Video Productions on Vimeo.

Your Reaction?
  • 13
  • LEGIT1
  • WOW0
  • LOL0
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP0
  • OB0
  • SHANK0

Continue Reading


TG2: The Zurich Classic has music? Best golf movie?



Music at the Zurich? Yes it is the Zurich, the team event where groups get to choose their walk up music. Looks like a bunch of groups picked the same song and we tell you what it is. What is the best and worst golf movie? We break down a couple and Rob tells us how he watched Masters Sunday!

Your Reaction?
  • 2
  • LEGIT0
  • WOW0
  • LOL0
  • IDHT0
  • FLOP1
  • OB0
  • SHANK2

Continue Reading

19th Hole